A Westmoreland County judge will not allow Alex Hribal to plead “guilty but mentally ill” to charges that he slashed or stabbed 20 fellow students and a security guard at Franklin Regional High School nearly three years ago, setting the stage for a probable trial.

Although the 19-year-old “may have suffered from a psychotic illness,” Common Pleas Judge Christopher A. Feliciani concluded in an opinion and court order Friday, it “did not cause him to substantially lack the capacity to appreciate the wrongfulness of his conduct or conform his behavior to the requirements of the law” on April 9, 2014.

Mr. Hribal’s attorney, Patrick Thomassey, sought the plea because it would have sent Mr. Hribal first to a mental health facility and then to a state prison to complete his sentence, if his condition improves. A defendant must have a “guilty but mentally ill” designation to receive such treatment and “it’s not like he gets the treatment, and he walks out,” Mr. Thomassey said.

“I’m very disappointed. I assume now we’ll proceed to trial, and I’ll see if 12 citizens from Westmoreland County believe he’s mentally ill or not,” he said. “My conscience won’t let me” allow him to plead guilty now.

Advertise with us

Authorities said Mr. Hribal used two kitchen knives from his Murrysville home in the attack for which he is charged as an adult with 21 counts each of attempted homicide and aggravated assault.

In the 14-page filing, Judge Feliciani cited Mr. Hribal’s “planning and preparation” in advance of the crime: selecting, then rescheduling, when to carry it out — both dates with significance — writing a manifesto that included grievances with society and researching the Columbine massacre, among other things.

“The Court finds that Hribal engaged in a well-organized and sophisticated plan to commit a deliberate act, namely killing as many people as possible,” he wrote.

Once Mr. Hribal was arrested, he said he no longer felt as if the Columbine perpetrators were “controlling him from hell” and said he realized his actions were wrong. “Dr. [Bruce] Wright testified that he never heard of an individual who had a psychotic disorder instantaneously improve,” the judge wrote of the prosecution’s psychiatrist.

Further, Judge Feliciani noted that Mr. Hribal’s statements to mental health professionals were inconsistent. He told one, for instance, that he didn’t recall the actual attack but told two others that he, in fact, did and that he felt empathy and sympathy for the victims.

Advertise with us

“As there are different accounts of psychotic symptoms to different professionals, it raises concern with this Court as to the reliability of a diagnosis of a psychotic disorder,” he wrote.

District Attorney John Peck has said he hadn’t seen evidence that Mr. Hribal’s mental conditions couldn’t be adequately treated in a state prison and that, based on the severity of the crimes, he didn’t want to do a disservice to the victims.

A pretrial conference has not yet been scheduled.

Molly Born: mborn@post-gazette.comor 412-263-1944.