As 19-year-old Seth Reid walked out of the fifth-floor courtroom Wednesday afternoon, he looked toward his mother, and said, “Who knew a fire extinguisher could ruin your life?”
It wasn’t much of an exaggeration.
Mr. Reid and his co-defendant, Damian Terrace, also 19, had just pleaded guilty to one count of institutional vandalism to school property.
According to investigators, about 10:30 a.m. on Jan. 14, the two high school seniors entered the newly remodeled Highlands High School auditorium and discharged a dry chemical fire extinguisher. The students were seen on security footage spraying it from the auditorium balcony. A large cloud of white powder then descended over the room, covering the seats, carpeting and stage curtains, said Catherine Russo, then the high school principal.
It caused $160,717 in damage.
Mr. Terrace’s defense attorney, Chris Urbano, tried to blame the incident on his client’s youth and poor decision making.
“It’s something, I’m quite certain, if he had to do over, he would,” the attorney said.
But Common Pleas Judge Beth A. Lazzara wasn’t buying it.
“His age doesn’t even begin to explain that,” she said. “[That amount] in damage is a little more than a bad decision.”
She lectured both defendants about the consequences of their actions.
“You just put yourself in a giant hole in life,” she said. “This is $160,000 for what? Total stupidity. You’re going to be living with the effects of this for the rest of your life.”
“I made a mistake without knowing what the consequences would be,” Mr. Terrace said. “I didn’t know the fire extinguisher would cause damage.”
Robert Marcus, who represented Mr. Reid, said his client was “ashamed, embarrassed and remorseful.”
Mr. Reid is in end-stage renal failure and must have dialysis three times per week after he was shot in a home invasion, Mr. Marcus said.
Judge Lazzara offered sympathy but said it didn’t change the outcome of the case. She ordered both men to serve two years of probation and also pay $10,000 in restitution — at a rate of $450 per month — to cover the district’s insurance deductible. “It’s your debt, not your parents’,” she told them.They are expected to be hit separately with a civil judgment for the remaining $150,717 that was paid by the district’s insurance carrier for the damage they caused.
Ms. Russo, who has known the students since they were in sixth grade, attended Wednesday’s hearing and said school administrators agreed to the reduction of the charge from a felony to a second-degree misdemeanor.
From the beginning of the investigation, she said, the teens, who were permitted to graduate but did not walk with their class, were cooperative and remorseful.
“They made a really dumb decision, and we want them to learn from their actions,” she said. “We knew that this would hinder them for the rest of their lives.”
Paula Reed Ward: pward@post-gazette.com, 412-263-2620 or on Twitter: @PaulaReedWard.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.