Pine-Richland school directors voted 5-to-4 Monday evening to approve a “sex-specific” resolution that requires transgender students to use bathrooms that match their biological gender or to utilize a unisex bathroom.
Spokeswoman Rachel Hathhorn said the district is reaching out today to its transgender students’ families to explain the change in policy. She declined to disclose how many families are impacted, saying the district believes that to give the group a number would be a violation of their privacy.
On the district’s written agenda for Monday's meeting, it was noted:
“For several months, the board and staff services committee has been reviewing the topics of privacy, transgender youth, and potential implications for the district. This is a topic of deliberation across the country. While the committee is not yet prepared to recommend a comprehensive policy, the board may consider action on this resolution.”
The resolution referenced in the agenda reads:
“This resolution agreed to by a majority of the board of directors of the Pine-Richland School District indicates our support to return to the long-standing practice of providing sex-specific facility usage. All students will have the choice of using either the facilities that correspond to their biological sex or unisex facilities. This practice will remain in place until such time that a policy may be developed and approved."
In July, neither of two distinct approaches regarding bathrooms for transgender students garnered enough support to be passed by the board.
One motion — which would have established a “sex-specific” protocol that required students to use a bathroom that matches their biological gender — failed on a 4-4 vote. Another motion — which would have allowed students to use a bathroom that matched their expressed and personal gender identity — also failed on a 4-4 vote.
The practice that had been in place last year and continued at the start of this year allowed transgender students to use the bathroom of the gender with which they identify, the private bathroom in the nurse's office, or a single-room unisex bathroom, according to a district spokesman who explained the practice at the time of the failed votes in July.
Voting in favor of the resolution on Monday were board members Greg DiTullio, Therese Dawson, Holly Johnston, Steven Stegman and Virginia Goebel. Voting against were Jeffrey Banyas, Dennis Sundo, Marc Casciani and Peter Lyons.
The new policy is contradictory to the guidelines in place at the U.S. Office of Civil Rights. Ms. Hathhorn said the district’s previous protocol was in line with those federal guidelines. She had no comment on the departure from those guidelines by virtue of Monday’s vote.
Karen Kane: kkane@post-gazette.com or at 724-772-9180.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.