Ally Mahon says she can accept the possibility that her parochial school might merge with another and that her kids might no longer keep going to the school at her parish, St. Bonaventure in Shaler. Numerous parish schools in Pittsburgh and throughout the country have already gone that route.
But what she would definitely oppose is any possibility of the Diocese of Pittsburgh — which plans a major restructuring in the face of a 50 percent drop in elementary school enrollment since the year 2000 — considering a break with the historic model of schools teaching students in kindergarten through eighth grade under the same roof.
No such recommendations have become public during ongoing discussions for On Mission for the Church Alive, the name of the ongoing restructuring in which the diocese is attempting to combine an evangelistic push with the need to get leaner amid declining vital signs ranging from Mass attendance to infant baptisms to enrollment.
This summer, the diocese has held numerous hearings on its restructuring process, and this fall it will begin airing models for proposed changes. A commission overseeing the process will make recommendations next year to Bishop David Zubik, who is scheduled to announce final plans in early 2018.
But the diocese has also said some changes could take place sooner if needed, and a recent bulletin announcement indicates that’s the case with financially struggling schools in the North Hills and Pittsburgh’s North Side.
It said regionalization plans are in the works for 11 schools with grades K-8 (and often preschool), spanning a wide expanse from Bellevue to Aspinwall to Pine. The goal is for final plans, once decided, to take effect in the 2017-18 school year, ahead of the larger On Mission for the Church Alive timetable.
What worries Ms. Mahon is that the diocese might be considering a model in which the younger students attend one set of schools and the older ones attend a middle school. With four children enrolled at St. Bonaventure this year in grades 1 through 5, that’s a big concern.
“We have no problem with the merger,” said Ms. Mahon, one of numerous parents sharing information among themselves through social media, where she said the vast majority hope to preserve the K-8 model. “We understand that Catholic schools need to do something to keep our numbers where they need to be and also obviously we don’t want tuition to rise to where people can’t afford it.”
But the K-8 model has numerous advantages, she said. Older students can watch over younger siblings or mentor newer students, and families in which both parents work full time are able to take their children to one location up until their high school years, making it easier to get kids to and from school and to focus their volunteering and fundraising on one institution. “It’s supposed to be about family values, and that is family values, keeping all your kids in one building,” she said.
Diocesan spokeswoman Ann Rodgers said the bulletin insert contained all of the information the diocese can discuss until school is back in session, when more detailed discussions will be had with all involved.
The bulletin announcement said that North Hills pastors asked Bishop Zubik for help in creating a regional model to “relieve financial pressure on parishes while helping to build enrollment and keep tuition affordable.”
It did not discuss any specific models and stressed in boldface that “no decisions have yet been made.”
The 11 schools affected include nine parish schools: St. Alexis in McCandless, St. Alphonsus in Pine, Assumption in Bellevue, St. Bonaventure in Shaler, St. Mary in Indiana Township, St. James in Sewickley, St. Sebastian and St. Teresa of Avila in Ross, and St. Ursula in Hampton. Also affected are two regional schools, Christ the Divine Teacher in Aspinwall and North Side Catholic in Brighton Heights.
Meredith Kandravy, who has three children at St. Mary School, said the diocese needs to bring parents in the planning process and convince them of the soundness of any regionalization.
“We really want Catholic education to succeed,” she said. “We are the people who are going to make this a success. If they do not have us on board, then the whole thing is going to be a failure.”
Peter Smith: petersmith@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1416; Twitter @PG_PeterSmith.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.