Come for the strawberry shortcake, but stay for the history.
The Burtner House in Harrison — one of the oldest standing structures in Allegheny County — will host its 42nd annual Strawberry Festival on Saturday.
“People come just to eat our strawberry shortcake, that’s how good it is,” said Lucy Mahdik, vice president of the Burtner House Restoration Society, who was busy cleaning the house last week prior to the Strawberry Festival.
The Burtner House, completed in 1821, has much to celebrate: 44 years ago, the historic house was nearly demolished by the construction of Route 28, which today is only a stone’s throw from the house on Burtner Road in the Natrona Heights section of the township. With a few hours to spare before the scheduled demolition of the house — and with a wrecking ball sitting by the front porch — the governor signed a bill declaring the Burtner House a historic landmark. State engineers immediately flew by helicopter to save the house.
The Burtner House boasts a rich history with ties to Pennsylvania and Pittsburgh. Meetings to plan the construction of the Pennsylvania Canal took place in the Burtner House. During the 1860 and 1864 presidential elections, the house was a local polling station. Abraham Lincoln carried Pennsylvania in both years.
“We have a gem in Natrona Heights, and people don’t realize that,” Ms. Mahdik said.
The history of the Burtner House is also intertwined with one of Pittsburgh’s oldest families, the Negleys — of Negley Avenue. In 1796, Philip Burtner and his business partner Felix Negley built a mill several miles from Natrona Heights, and Felix Negley was married to Philip Burtner’s first daughter.
Since the death in 1972 of the house’s last resident, Holmes Burtner, responsibility for the property has lain with the Burtner House Restoration Society, a group of local community members who support the house with donations and volunteer work. When the house changed hands after Holmes Burtner’s death, it was in disrepair.
“It was really doomsday,” Ms. Mahdik said.
The Burtner House has three second-floor bedrooms, two first-floor living rooms, an attic and a basement, but no bathroom. (Ms. Mahdik is quick to point out that the outhouse in the backyard is a two-seater.)
It took Philip Burtner three years to build the house, and no wonder. The house’s stone walls are more than a foot thick and the house has four large fireplaces.
“Back in 1821, this place was considered a mansion,” said Jeff Jones, president of the Burtner House Restoration Society.
Today the house is furnished throughout with artifacts donated by hundreds of remaining Burtner descendants living across the country, Mr. Jones said. Antique dolls, wood cabinets and a four-post bed keep the house’s ambiance grounded in the 19th century.
Among the many oddities in the house is a functional “goat butter churn” in the basement.
The contraption resembles a small wooden treadmill hitched to a butter churn; the goat — or dog, as the case may be — is tethered to the machine and made to walk, churning the butter as the animal moves.
In 1800, when Philip Burtner arrived at the site where four generations of his family would live, he came as a squatter, building a small “settler’s cabin” on the acreage. It was not until after he had farmed the land that the site’s owner permitted him to buy the property and build the house that stands there today. The Burtner property once sprawled across 250 acres but has since shrunk to 16.5 acres.
The Strawberry Festival was established both to showcase the house and to celebrate the region’s history. Ms. Mahdik estimated that about 75 percent of festivalgoers each year are newcomers.
At the festival, Civil War re-enactors will set up camp near the Burtner House, musicians will play period music, and horse and buggy rides will take festivalgoers along nearby Pleasantville Road. Artisans will showcase homemade soap and beeswax, and an Abraham Lincoln impersonator will regale visitors with antebellum tales.
“Our Abraham Lincoln is to die for,” Ms. Mahdik said.
The festival brings in an average $3,000 for the preservation of the house each summer, she said.
The Strawberry Festival will be held from 11 a.m. to 5 p.m. Saturday. The entrance fee is $5 for adults, $2 for ages 12-18 and free for children under 12.
The Burtner House is also open for tours every third Sunday from July to September.
Finnegan Schick: fschick@post-gazette.com.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.