A good cup of coffee and a comfortable phone booth.
As a career salesman, that's all Matt Matesic said he needed to ply his trade, and for years he knew he could reliably find both at the Venus Diner on Route 8 in Hampton.
“I’d meet with my sales staff there in the morning, and we’d have breakfast and go over our gameplan,” Mr. Matesic said. “I could make my calls from anywhere so I liked to have their coffee and use their payphone. And I’d stop at the end of the day too for a slice of pie. They had great pie there.”
After a 52-year run of crackling bacon, sizzling eggs, griddled pancakes, and yes, fresh pies, The Venus closed in 2009. But the vintage diner began a second life on Monday in a south Minneapolis neighborhood as the Hi-Lo Diner. How it went from North Hills institution to new Minneapolis landmark is a tale woven between classic Americana and the changing palates of American diners.
Opened in 1957, the Venus took its name because it was in the orbit of nearby Mars, Pa., Brian Butko, the Director of Publications at the Heinz History Center said. In 1999, Mr. Butko wrote a book on the topic, “Diners of Pennsylvania.”
He said that the Venus, a Fodero-style diner, with its rounded corners and a stainless steel sunburst design, was “at that height of the style. That late 1950’s exaggerated modern look after the Art Deco period. It had bigger windows, bigger pieces of stainless steel. And it had these big shiny chrome mirrors on the ceiling so that the waitresses could look up and see who needed their coffee cups refilled.”
Read More
“It was a disappointment to see it pulled out of here,” Mr. Butko said. “Pittsburgh has never had the volume of classic diners the way Eastern Pennsylvania, Philadelphia and New Jersey have.”
Mr. Butko said that the popularity of diners have ebbed and flowed throughout decades.
“I remember in the late 80’s the word diner was poisoned. It hadn’t gotten its post modern resurgence. People would say why do you like those greasy spoons? The 1990’s saw a revival, but now again many are being remodeled and bulldozed out of existence.”
That makes the Venus’s second act all the more notable.
Back in Minnesota, Mike Smith and James Brown had for eight years looked out their office windows and across the street at a vacant and dilapidated former Taco Bell location. The partners in Brownsmith Restoration, a design company, grew tired of the eyesore and brainstormed on something creative to take its place to help revitalize their patch of urban Minneapolis.
Different ideas were kicked around, Hi-Lo marketing manager Rebekah Cook said that after reading an article online, Mr. Brown walked over to his partner’s office and asked, “What if we buy a diner and put it in front of the Taco Bell?”
Mr. Smith simply responded, “Yes.”
They got in touch with Steve Harwin who since 1987 has bought old diners, shipped them to his Cleveland workshop, Diversified Diners, restored them and sold them to new owners in new locations.
Mr. Harwin, who began his career fixing and restoring classic cars and motorcycles moved into diner restoration after buying a 1942 diner in Beaver County.
“I must have been optimistic because I didn’t actually know anything about diners,” he laughed. He went on to do dozens of full and partial restorations.
“I found one — The Pole Tavern Diner in New Jersey — that had trees growing in it, it had been empty so long. They basically gave it to me. It turned out to be one of my nicer restorations. It went to Michigan to the private estate of a Ford Motor Co. executive for his summer property.”
Mr. Harwin wouldn’t divulge the sale price for the Venus except to say “I had to buy all the kitchen equipment with it so I paid more than I typically would.”
“It cost $10,000 just to move it to Cleveland and it was a three-day job getting it off its foundation and on to a truck,” he said. The restoration was no less difficult.
“That one was a killer,” he said. “I thought it was in better condition than it actually was so it took me a year and a half at least. When I get them in I do the roof first, which took a couple weeks. It was really in bad shape. I had to take all the metal off and replace the wood. It was intense just getting roof done. Then you just tear it down as far as you have to.
“People ask me, what do you have to do? And I say, the diner tells me. You start working on it and find out you have to go way further than you might expect. A case in point is the Venus. I needed to reinforce the entire structure, which was very expensive.”
Ms. Cook said the entire project, from the first whiff of an idea to the opening of doors on Monday, took 2 years and cost $1.4 million. Just as the Venus derived its name from nearby Mars, the Hi-Lo is named as such because it is near the intersection of the Hiawatha and Longfellow neighborhoods in South Minneapolis.
Mr. Harwin said he likes to visit his restorations after they open for business and intends to do the same with the Hi-Lo.
“I go to a lot of diners and have a lot of good meals,” he said.
When he visits he can expect not classic diner food in an iconic setting, but also made-to-order fresh donuts, and craft cocktails. Co-partners in the venture are the owners of the Blue Door Pub, a chain of successful gastropubs in the Twin Cities.
Ms. Cook there was a line down the street to herald its arrival in a high-traffic area where 15,000 cars pass by each day. If the background cacophony of customers’ voices and clanging dishes overheard during a reporter’s phone call is any indication, they’re off to a good start.
“We’ve had diner fanatics from all over the world wanting to know where we are,” she said, adding that she’s also heard from former Venus customers who now live in Minnesota.
“We just had someone email us that said “I used to eat at the Venus every morning — holy cow you just blew my mind!”
As for his old sales stop, Richland’s Mr. Matesic said he’s glad to hear that it’s in good hands.
“Too many people just pull into a Sheetz and tap the screen for their food,” he said. “An old-timer like me, I’d rather spend time in a diner like that.”
Dan Gigler: dgigler@post-gazette.com; Twitter @gigs412





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.