The Armstrong County Jail has suspended its inmate trusty program and plans to subject it to an outside review following the escape last week of a trusty who police say killed a woman while on the lam.
Even as the warden halted the program — which confers special status to a handful of nonviolent offenders, allowing them to do labor such as mowing lawns at county facilities — the county prison board said it intends to hire an independent consultant to scrutinize the jail’s use and selection of trusties, examine best practices and pick through the circumstances leading to Robert E. Crissman Jr.’s ability to escape last Thursday.
“We want the third-party investigator to review the policies, look at our trusty program, how it’s been handled, and also how they get through that process,” prison board president Richard L. Fink said.
Police say Crissman was outside the Kittanning-area facility early that morning waiting to assist a van delivering food trays when he ran away. Several hours later, according to investigators, Crissman beat and strangled Tammy Long, 55, in her Rayburn home nearby. Crissman evaded authorities until the next morning, when he was captured after a high-speed pursuit and crash.
Crissman’s flight was not the first time a trusty has escaped, Mr. Fink said. In February 2014, an inmate named Zachary Eckman, who was in the jail on a bench warrant and probation violation, failed to report back after completing his scheduled work release program with the county public works department, according to court documents and Mr. Fink. Eckman was spotted, tackled and taken into custody a short time later.
Read More
Jason Lewis, the prison board’s solicitor, said the jail has specific policies governing inmate trusties. He refused to release the policies, citing anticipated litigation.
“Those policies were followed,” Mr. Lewis said.
Both he and Mr. Fink, who is also a county commissioner, said no one at the jail has been disciplined in connection with Crissman’s escape. Nevertheless, the six-member prison board met Wednesday with Mr. Lewis in a 45-minute private executive session to discuss personnel issues at the jail as well as the possibility of lawsuits stemming from the escape.
“I think there is a great potential for litigation to be filed,” Mr. Fink said.
Mr. Fink said his recommendation to hire a consultant would formally be made at an open meeting of the prison board Monday.
But with the board holding a closed-door meeting, official secrecy continued to reign over the situation. On Friday, Crissman was arraigned in secret — despite media objections — at the Pennsylvania State Police barracks in Kittanning. District Judge James H. Owen presided over the proceeding, but state police barred reporters from entering the area where the arraignment took place and witnessing what transpired.
During a preliminary arraignment, bail is set and defendants are informed of the charges against them, provided a copy of the criminal complaint and read their rights.
Both Judge Owen and the barracks’ ranking officer, Lt. Stephen M. Russo, maintained that preliminary arraignments are not open to the public, a contention that the Pennsylvania NewsMedia Association and the American Civil Liberties Union of Pennsylvania said is wrong.
On Wednesday morning, county President Judge Kenneth G. Valasek, who supervises the minor judiciary, said Judge Owen erred in the way he went about barring the public and the news media from Crissman’s arraignment. The president judge said he would draft a memo “reminding them of the presumption of openness in the courts … the memorandum will set forth a protocol on how to go about making a proper decision on whether to exclude the public from a court proceeding.”
Judge Valasek said he had spoken with Judge Owen about the situation.
“… The mistake that Judge Owen made was not notifying the press in advance and not advancing a reason at the time, whatever his reason may have been,” Judge Valasek said.
Judge Owen said Wednesday afternoon he had not seen Judge Valasek’s statement. He declined to discuss his rationale for closing the arraignment, asked why reporters were peppering him with questions and stated, “I’m not sure that a preliminary arraignment is a hearing.”
Trooper Adam Reed, the state police spokesman in Harrisburg, said in an email that the decision to hold the arraignment at the barracks was made after Lt. Russo consulted with the district attorney and Judge Owen. It was made “with security and the need to continue the investigation in mind,” Trooper Reed said. “The investigation was extremely active and timeliness was key when the preliminary arraignment was held. Additionally, there were security concerns that prompted the decision to hold it at the barracks.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.