Rhonda McGuirk admitted to having some misgivings when she and her husband, Rick, bought their house in Harmony in 1985. A handsome home on a secluded dead-end street, it also was within 150 feet of Interstate 79, which sits on a steep slope above their backyard.

But there was a thick stand of trees between the house and the highway that obscured the view and knocked down some of the noise. "We had lots of shade, and it was just gorgeous," Ms. McGuirk said.

The McGuirks were pleased with their decision until progress paid a visit two years ago. That's when the Pennsylvania Department of Transportation began a long-discussed $18 million project to add the "missing ramps" at the Little Creek Road interchange.

Down came the trees, more than 100 of them by Ms. McGuirk's estimate. In went a drainage ditch. The McGuirks now have an unobstructed view of the expressway and its full soundtrack.

Advertise with us

They also have more traffic, as a new northbound off-ramp brings vehicles that formerly exited a mile earlier, including those headed to the Seneca Valley School District campus and a local landfill. And they have louder traffic, as heavy trucks use their "jake brakes" to slow down on the ramp.

PG VIDEO

What they don't have is satisfaction with PennDOT's remediation plans. "They act nice and they act like they're helping you," Ms. McGuirk said. "But they have an agenda."

She said her first choice when the project was announced was to have the department buy the house. But PennDOT didn't need the property to build the new ramps.

She asked for a sound wall, also to no avail, even though PennDOT is building one on the other side of the highway, where there are more houses.

Advertise with us

PennDOT did not build a sound wall above the McGuirk house because the department "is a responsible steward of taxpayer dollars and needs to operate within the federal guidelines for sound mitigation," spokeswoman Deborah Casadei said.

"Noise-sensitive areas are determined following a model approved by the Federal Highway Administration. This model takes into account many factors including traffic counts of vehicles and distances from the residence to the roadway," she said.

"A noise study, consistent with the approved model, was conducted to determine if a noise wall would be warranted ... if it would be feasible to construct it and if it was reasonable. The study showed that a noise wall was warranted for the west side of I-79. On the east side of I-79, where the McGuirks' house sits, the study showed that all of the warrants were not met," she said.

She said she is ambivalent about PennDOT's latest proposal, which is to plant fast-growing willow shoots in the drainage channel.

Brian Steffy, assistant construction engineer for PennDOT District 10, which includes Butler County, said the willows would address two complaints Ms. McGuirk has raised. They would absorb standing water in the ditch and grow quickly, creating a visual buffer. Evergreen trees planted on the slope behind neighboring homes will take years to fill in, he noted.

Advertise with us

PennDOT has corresponded frequently and met with the McGuirks, but Mr. Steffy said he has concluded that there is just no satisfying the couple. "Throughout the project we have been unable to do that," he said.

He also disagreed that the project has had a negative impact on their property. "It was our right of way. They knew it whenever they bought [the house]. ... It's hard to say we impacted it just because we built a project on our right of way."

"It's unfortunate that PennDOT has come in and ruined what we have," Ms. McGuirk said. "We liked it the way it was. I want this restored."