State Sen. Jane Orie acknowledged that thank-you notes for fund-raisers were prepared and printed in her legislative office, and she conceded that she at times "got lazy" and used her state e-mail account to issue political directives to her staff.
But she continued to insist during testimony in her public corruption trial this morning that, as far as she knew, political work by her staffers was performed using compensatory time off or vacation days. She said that her former chief of staff, Jamie Pavlot, a person she regarded "almost as a sister," was in day-to-day control of an office where, according to numerous witnesses, political work was done on state time.
She also insisted that neither Ms. Pavlot nor anyone else had informed her of the complaints of some employees who balked at performing political chores.
"I was never, ever aware of [the] complaints," she said.
Ms. Orie and her sister, Janine Orie, are facing charges in Allegheny County Common Pleas Court that they used the senator's state-paid office and staff to do political work for her and another sister, Supreme Court Justice Joan Orie Melvin.
Through the first hours of a painstaking cross examination this morning, the North Hills Republican and chief prosecutor Lawrence Claus sparred in consistently civil tones as she offered explanations for some of the incriminating testimony amassed before the jury during the prosecution case.
Ms. Orie said that though thank-you notes for fund-raisers were prepared on office computers, she felt that she had compensated the state by paying for the stamps and stationery. She acknowledged that some of her staffers earned comp time for attending the Allegheny County GOP's Lincoln Day dinner. While that event is the party's largest annual fund-raiser, she portrayed it as a crypto-legislative forum where she reported on public policy for the assembled committee members and donors.
When asked about testimony that her staffers had used the event as an opportunity to circulate nominating petitions for her sister, Justice Joan Orie Melvin, she gave a discursive answer. She acknowledged that she had seen the petitions for the Supreme Court race on tables manned by her staffers, but suggested that she hadn't actually seen her staffers circulating them.
Ms. Orie described her role at the dinner as "performing my duties as a senator."
That depiction contrasted with the characterization by Judge Jeffrey Manning, who said earlier in the trial, outside of the hearing of the jurors, that anyone who doesn't know that the dinner is political doesn't know the sun rises in the east.
Mr. Claus led the defendant through a lengthy review of e-mails exchanged with a former staffer, Joe Smith, over the logistics for a 2005 fund-raising event.
In one, she told Mr. Smith, "Joe, you are to be making [fund-raising] calls all day today and tomorrow."
She maintained that she assumed, based on her abundant instructions in the past, that Mr. Smith knew to use comp time for the work.
"I said, get out of the office, take the time and get it done," she said, explaining the directives. She acknowledged that the e-mails were sent on state accounts and said, "I get lazy ??? rather than get on AOL. I was remiss."
Continuing a theme from her direct questioning, she repeatedly described Ms. Pavlot, her former chief of staff, as the hand-on overseer of an office she would sometimes not visit extended periods of time.
"For the day-to-day [decisions on comp time] who was getting, who was submitting, that was her," she said of her longtime lieutenant.
"I was not aware on a day-to-day basis what Jamie did," she said at another point.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.