GREENVILLE, Pa. -- In a classic swing district in a classic swing state, there is something unclassifiable going on.

U.S. Rep. Kathy Dahlkemper is the only freshman Democrat running for re-election in Pennsylvania this year, in a district that tapped her over a seven-term Republican in 2008, but still favored John McCain for president. GOP leaders including Sarah Palin are targeting her seat, and the Republican race for the party's bid -- which has more candidates than any other statewide -- is the most vibrant one northwest Pennsylvania has seen in decades.

There is another sign of these uncharacteristic times. Only one of the six GOP candidates, Butler car dealer and former city Councilman Mike Kelly, 61, has ever held office.

"Please do not take this the wrong way," he said in a candidate forum last week hosted by the Mercer County GOP in a Greenville fire hall. "I do not think that we would be in this trouble if people like us had run for office before."

Advertise with us

The line drew applause from the 60 souls filling the hall, as did complaints from all the candidates about the health care reform bill, the stimulus package, illegal immigration, Ms. Dahlkemper, Nancy Pelosi and, most of all, Barack Obama.

"People ask me 'How are you going to work with Obama?' I'm not planning to work with him. I'm going to cut him off at the knees," said Butler County pharmaceutical salesman Clayton Grabb, 48. "I'm going to pull the support out from under him so he can't do any more damage to this nation of ours."

Freshmen who squeak by in their first elections (Ms. Dahlkemper lost five of seven counties to Republican Phil English two years ago) are usually ripe for re-election challenges, often from established members of the other party. That did not happen in the 3rd District -- the GOP did not land a big name, or one from Erie County, which holds the most votes (of both parties) districtwide.

"There was a void," said former Erie GOP Chairman Brad Moore, "and it became an opportunity for an everyman-type campaign. You could come from business or any walk of life and make a run."

Pennsylvania has more competitive congressional races than any state nationwide, in a midterm election year dominated by talk of the economy. The 3rd District -- which includes Erie and parts of Armstrong, Butler, Crawford, Mercer, Venango and Warren counties -- has a unique place in that debate, with two of the worst unemployment rates in the state. (The Warren area's 14 percent rate in March was the highest in Pennsylvania, followed by Philadelphia and then Erie, which was at 10.6 percent.)

Advertise with us

Talk about the Democrats' handling of the economy dominated a debate last Monday at Allegheny College in Meadville, attended by a large weeknight crowd of 130, said Dan Shea, a political science professor and director of its Center for Political Participation.

"If there is a perception that a party in power is weak, more candidates emerge and better candidates emerge. That's why Democrats are in deep trouble," he said.

Debates over business acumen have marked the primary race. Crawford County's Paul Huber, 65, stakes a claim as the candidate with the most experience in that realm, as the former owner of Seco-Warwick, a Meadville-area industrial heating equipment manufacturer, who grew up on a farm and still raises cattle.

"There are three ways to create wealth -- mine it, grow it, make it -- and I've done it all. No other candidate can say that," he says. Mr. Huber has a jobs plan that calls for simplifying taxes, cutting business regulation and implementing tort reform, among other measures.

Mr. Huber gets flak on the trail for being Democrat until 2008 but says that could serve him well in the fall in a district with a Democratic registration edge. "I am a lifelong social and fiscal conservative," he said. "That's what people will judge me on -- and there are a lot of conservative Democrats in this area."

Advertise with us

Mr. Kelly, the Butler GM dealer, also touts his business experience, while also regularly mentioning his time as a lineman for Notre Dame football coach Ara Parseghian in the mid-1960s. He is a fiery and engaging on the stump, leading Mr. Huber to say at the Allegheny forum last week that the district needs "a workhorse, not a showhorse."

"I'm flattered. I'd rather be described as a racehorse. No question about that," Mr. Kelly said in an interview.

National Republicans see the pair as the frontrunners in the primary, as they have the most money and have been the only two to advertise on television. Ad money goes a long way in the 3rd, as it costs only about $20,000 per week to be on air (for comparison, it is $800,000 weekly in Philadelphia). Through March 31, Mr. Huber raised $417,000 for his bid, much of it through a $250,000 personal loan. Mr. Kelly posted $218,000, with a $165,000 loan.

But being an establishment candidate could have its dangers in this unpredictable year. "It's sort of David versus Goliath," Mercer County conservative activist and blogger Roberta Biros said, of the gap between Mr. Huber and Mr. Kelly and the other candidates.

Two of those Davids -- group health insurance salesman Steve Fisher and factory worker Ed Franz, both of Crawford County -- have broken with others on the slate by criticizing the Supreme Court's allowance of corporate campaign spending, saying it quashes the voices of regular voters. (They don't like spending by labor unions either.)

Advertise with us

"Where I part with a lot of the other candidates is they've never had a conversation with average taxpayers and their families," said Mr. Franz, 48, a worker at the GE locomotive plant in Erie, and a former campaign volunteer for Rick Santorum and Phil English. "They may campaign on conservative issues, but once they get to Washington they won't remember them."

Mr. Grabb -- a tea party activist and Navy vet with a distinctive flat-top crewcut -- has a similar anti-establishment message. "I feel like I have a righteous wind at my back," he said. "With these high-priced campaigns, by the time we get through the primary we'll have a false choice in the general. It's big money versus big money."

Mr. Fisher and the sixth candidate in the primary -- Mercer County family practitioner Martha Moore -- have made health care the cornerstone of their campaigns. Like most of the others, they are political neophytes.

"I was down in D.C. last year in meetings on health care reform and someone said, 'If you don't want to find yourself becoming part of the menu, you have to take seat at the table,' " said Mr. Fisher, a 26-year insurance veteran. Health insurance is "the appetizer, main course and dessert right now. You can't just complain -- you have to take a seat."

Dr. Moore, 53, is a former CPA who went to medical school after working alongside missionaries in Papua New Guinea, and is known on the campaign trail for reciting Ronald Reagan quotes by memory.

Advertise with us

"I'm on the front lines, as a family physician, seeing what this health bill can do to patients with our tax dollars," she said. "Our bureaucracy needs to be audited."

Ms. Dahlkemper's approval of health care reform -- which she voted for in November and again in March (joining Michigan Rep. Bart Stupak and other anti-abortion Democrats at the 11th hour) -- will be a main part of the Republican attack in the fall, but she sees it winning her votes in the long term, campaign spokeswoman Tina Mengine said.

"Since the vote there has been very positive feedback about it. Once the changes go into effect people will realize it's not Armageddon. They will be more comfortable as time goes on," she said.

The member of the conservative Blue Dog Democrat faction has tried to position herself as a moderate, voting against cap-and-trade environmental legislation but in favor of the $787 billion stimulus last year. (In February, National Journal ranked her among the most centrist members of the House.)

The economy is "moving in the right direction -- every economic indicator is showing signs of improvement and the economy is getting people back to work," her spokeswoman said. "It's hard to convince people, but we were on the brink of depression if we had not acted, and it would be much worse today."

Ms. Dahlkemper faces a primary challenge May 18 from little-known conservative Erie Democrat Mel Marin, a former investment banker. Libertarian Bill Beeman also plans to run in the fall. The congresswoman has a big head start over all challengers in campaign fundraising with $856,000 in cash.