State Sen. Jane Orie said she wasn't trying to slight Butler County Republicans when she sent a letter to the governor supporting Butler County Public Defender Kevin Flaherty for the vacant post of magisterial district judge in Cranberry.
"I had an obligation to move forward on this in a timely fashion,'' she said in an interview Tuesday, explaining why she made the recommendation without the input she had requested earlier from local Republicans.
In the meantime, the committee that formed to give the senator input announced Tuesday it is not supporting Mr. Flaherty for the vacancy, though the chairman of that committee declined to identify who had won the panel's unanimous backing.
"They are welcome to make a recommendation,'' said the senator, noting that the nomination for the vacant post ultimately will be made by Gov. Ed Rendell, then voted on by the Senate.
Ms. Orie, a Republican, sent the letter of support for Mr. Flaherty, who recently changed his registration from Democrat to Republican, in early January, about a month after she asked F. Arthur Rauschenberger III, chairman of the Butler County Republican Committee, to weigh in on the matter.
But the senator said Mr. Rauschenberger took too long to get back to her so she recommended Mr. Flaherty, whom she said had broad support from "numerous" township residents as well as respected attorneys and judges throughout the county.
Furthermore, she said, she had no obligation to consult with the county Republicans but did so out of deference to the fact that the seat had previously been held by a Republican. The post was left vacant when District Judge Kelley Streib was installed as a county Common Pleas judge on Jan. 4.
"I feel very comfortable with my decision. He is exceptionally qualified for the post, and he has overwhelming support from the community,'' the senator said.
Mr. Rauschenberger said he was "confused" when he heard from Mr. Flaherty that he had won the senator's support before his committee gave her formal input. It has been tradition in Pennsylvania for the governor to weigh heavily on the recommendation of the state senator in whose district a vacant district judgeship occurs.
"The senator had called me in December and asked me for a recommendation. I told her that I thought it was best that it be done by committee,'' he explained. So, he appointed the members of both the county and state Republican Committees as well as two local attorneys.
But before the group had a chance to meet Monday, he heard that the senator already had made a recommendation.
Though Mr. Rauschenberger received confirmation from the senator's office that a recommendation had been forwarded to Mr. Rendell, he said he decided to proceed with convening the committee. "That's what I said I would do, so that's what we did,'' Mr. Rauschenberger said.
Ms. Orie said Mr. Rauschenberger "dropped the ball" by not convening his committee sooner.
Mr. Rauschenberger said the senator had not given him a deadline for forwarding to her input on the matter and that the timing of the request -- during the Christmas holiday season -- made it difficult to convene a meeting earlier. He also said he felt it was appropriate to wait until the post was actually vacant before suggesting a candidate for the vacancy.
The senator said she was under pressure from local court officials to have the post filled as soon as possible and that other senators had submitted recommendations to the governor for vacancies within their districts.
"I don't have any conflict with Art [Rauschenberger] and I'm not trying to slight anyone. But I needed to proceed with this. I try to be pretty diligent about things,'' Ms. Orie said.
Mr. Rauschenberger said four candidates, including Mr. Flaherty, were interviewed and one, not Mr. Flaherty, was recommended unanimously. He said the committee agreed not to identify the candidates or its recommendation.
The candidates were two attorneys and two others, all from Cranberry, he said, and the committee members evaluated them on an array of considerations, including education, work experience, temperament and work ethic.
Mr. Rauschenberger said the committee's recommendation was forwarded to the governor's office. He said he advised each of the candidates to send a resume and a request for consideration to the governor.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.