The two North Allegheny school board candidates who are likely fighting for the same seat agree that financial stability and quality education are at the core of any sound school system.
But while the incumbent, Scott Cunningham, points to the all-Republican current board's record of success, the Democratic challenger, Carole Shepard, spots blemishes on both fronts.
At the same time, the two are not as far apart on all issues as one might expect.
Five seats are up for election and there are six candidates. Four have been cross-nominated -- incumbents Beth Ann Ludwig, Maureen Grosheider, Karen Boujoukos and Alan Shuckrow. Mr. Cunningham won only as a Republican and Ms. Shepard as a Democrat.
"The most important issue that I have with this board is accountability," Ms. Shepard said, concerning decisions about "how our resources are directed in both the financial and the education arena."
Ms. Shepard, 51, a speech pathologist from McCandless who has worked with various districts, said North Allegheny should have cut property taxes by more than 0.38 mills for 2007-08 since its reserves are more than adequate.
Mr. Cunningham, 48, a financial manager for PNC Wealth Management Group who lives in Marshall, voted for the $110.2 million spending plan because it included modest relief for taxpayers. But he, too, said the district could have afforded a somewhat larger cut that would have still allowed North Allegheny to cover one year's worth of bond payments from its surplus.
The two are in even closer step in opposing the board's decision to continue appealing property tax assessments it deems too low.
"It would be nice to see how the legal fees we are paying compare to the money collected," Ms. Shepard said, "and balance it with the tremendous ill will we have created.
"The idea is to have people want to move into the district, not avoid it."
Mr. Cunningham joined Ralph Pagone and Mr. Shuckrow in opposing the appeals, which a board majority had said they authorized because the failed county assessment system left them little choice.
One of the issues where Ms. Shepard and Mr. Cunningham are in stark disagreement concerns a series of professional conference trips that various school officials are taking next year.
The three trips to Tampa, New Orleans and Orlando take place between February and April. Ms. Grosheider is going on all three, along with Superintendent Patricia Green, while board President Linda Bishop is going to two and board members Ms. Boujoukos and Ms. Ludwig are going to Orlando. Ms. Ludwig, the overall top vote-getter in May, has agreed to cover her own airfare to save money.
The total costs are expected to be between $6,000 and $10,000. Ms. Shepard said the trips are frivolous and the costs were not disclosed in a forthright manner.
Like the board majority, Mr. Cunningham said such conferences provide valuable insights that inform board decisions and explore cutting-edge trends.
The real mistake, he said, was that the board had chosen not to travel to such conferences enough in years past when issues such as unfunded state mandates were at the fore.
"Not spending a few hundreds on travel has cost us hundred of thousands in unfunded mandates," he said.
It is Mr. Shuckrow who holds a view most similar to Ms. Shepard on the out-of-town trips. He, along with board member Pagone, opposed the expenditures, while those making the trips abstained.
Mr. Shuckrow didn't have a problem with any particular trip, but said that three in two months seemed excessive.
His overriding concern, however, was that the board may be placing too much emphasis on a Top 100 ranking, using trips like this to promote that misguided focus.
Ms. Shepard takes that one step further.
When it comes to educational issues, she said North Allegheny is entrenched in a teach-to-the-test mind set that can undercut lifetime learning.
Another problem, she said, is the reluctance of the board to push Ms. Green to act on well-thought curriculum updates recommended by the faculty, particularly concerning technology.
She also pointed to North Allegheny's opposition to two key initiatives that could appeal to a broader spectrum of its students -- the stalled upgrade at A.W. Beattie Career Center in McCandless and the Chinese language program that was launched there despite North Allegheny's opposition.
"I have yet to find someone, anyone, who can tell me when we will know we are one of the Top 100 schools in the country," she said, adding that "our pursuit of banners has many of our students lost in the shuffle."
Mr. Cunningham, meanwhile, said the board's record speaks for itself and that "the opposition is quibbling with success."
Though he's not obsessing over his cellar-dwelling ballot position -- a stroke of bad luck caused by winning as a Republican only and the use of touch screens -- he has adopted a new campaign slogan of "Saving the best for last."
He points to several accomplishments the board has gained since 2001.
Beginning with a $2 million deficit, the budget is balanced with a reasonably sized nest egg.
Carson and Ingomar Middle Schools renovations were completed on time and under budget.
He said North Allegheny has undertaken an extensive curriculum review and began a renewed emphasis on instruction. And just two weeks ago, the district upgraded its high-speed computer network.
As for the drive to produce top students, Mr. Cunningham sees nothing wrong with a district focused on quantifying excellence.
"Lastly and most proudly," he said, "our students' achievement test scores and SAT test scores are the highest they have ever been."




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.