Butler County voters spurned one incumbent, rewarded another and gave an unexpected nod to a dark-horse newcomer who acknowledged that even she was surprised by her win in a hotly contested race among a dozen candidates for county commissioner.
Republican Scott Lowe, chairman of the county commissioners, was unsuccessful in his bid for his party's nomination in Tuesday's primary. The news was better for Commissioner James Kennedy, though the top vote-getter on the GOP ballot was businessman Dale Pinkerton. According to unofficial tabulations, Mr. Pinkerton had about 26.3 percent of the votes cast compared with Mr. Kennedy's 25.6 percent. Mr. Lowe had 20.6 percent.
On the Democratic side, Linda Volaric, of Fairview, who helps run her family's construction business, was the shock of the evening as she came out early as the No. 2 person on a slate of seven candidates. She was bested by Jim Lokhaiser, of Franklin, a radio sportscaster and former transit employee. Mr. Lokhaiser claimed about 18 percent of the votes cast, compared with Ms. Volaric's 16 percent. Jack Beiler, of Penn, a retired Mellon Bank executive, was a nose away at roughly 15 percent.
The top two nominees from each party will appear on the ballot in the November election and voters will be asked to pick three of the four. The three winners will be elected to four-year terms that begin next year.
As the top GOP vote-getter, Mr. Pinkerton, 67, of Butler, a retired assistant district manager for Goodyear and a former store owner, said he believed his community service and business know-how garnered his nomination.
"My wife, Millie, and I have done a lot in the community. We've been co-chairs for United Way, I'm big in Rotary, and Millie does a lot for the YMCA. People don't forget that," he said, adding that his decades as a businessman helped establish a reputation of integrity.
Mr. Pinkerton has had a varied career that included being a licensed funeral director and supervising and manning Goodyear wholesale and retail stores, including the store in Butler. He was assistant district manager for Goodyear wholesale as well.
He sold his Butler store in 2005. He served on the Butler Parking Authority for 15 years.
Mr. Kennedy, 63, of Middlesex, a lifelong dairy farmer who took office in 1996, said he was relieved to be past the primary election stage.
"I'm grateful to the voters for giving me a spot on the ballot, and I believe I had the best bunch of volunteers any candidate could have," Mr. Kennedy said.
He had no comment on Mr. Lowe's loss.
"I'm just staying focused on me and my positive campaign. My message is the same as it's been from the beginning: I'm about fiscal responsibility and I point to my track record of leadership on all kinds of issues, from economic development to the agriculture community," he said.
As the lead Democratic nominee, Mr. Lokhaiser, 71, said he believed he did his campaigning over most of his life. "I didn't do any door-knocking. I think I did that over the past 50 years with all the people I know and all the things I've been involved in," he said.
He will change tactics in the fall, however. He said he planned to go door to door heavily in an effort to get his message to Republicans and Democrats.
Mr. Lokhaiser spent many years in the media, starting in radio at WBUT in Butler in 1959, then adding television to his resume in 1975, when he was hired by Armstrong Cable to put a show on the air. He did a talk show, sports and local news, enjoying a two-year run.
He worked as an assistant superintendant in Butler at the Pennsylvania Department of Transportation for four years, then accepted a post as project coordinator for the Downtown Butler Renaissance Commission in the early 1980s, coordinating the start of public transit in Butler via the Butler County Transit Authority. He ran the Armstrong County Public Transit system from 1989 to 1991. Most recently, he worked for Mike Kelly Chevrolet in Butler Township in marketing, advertising and sales. He is active in the annual Butler County Farm Show and American Legion baseball and volunteers with the United Way and YMCA.
No one might be more surprised about Ms. Volaric's win than Ms. Volaric.
"I didn't have a lot of money to spend. I didn't have a lot of people working for me. I just can't believe it turned out this way. I was in tears," she said.
She believes that being "a regular person, not a politician," with a message of good-paying jobs for more people resounded with the public.
"I tried to get out as much as a I could. I talked to people. I listened. I learned a lot. And now I'm going to focus on the fall," she said.
Politically speaking, Ms. Volaric, 49, is as green as she could be. She never before had sought or held political office. She was "downsized" in 2003, losing her job at a chemical company in Petrolia, and has since been helping to run her family's construction business while raising a 10-year-old son with her husband, Glenn.
"I think people see that I'm one of them," she said.
While four of 12 candidates celebrated, Mr. Lowe was trying to absorb the shock of not securing his party's nomination.
"I'll be spending a lot of time thinking about what happened," he said.
He said he was surprised and disappointed by the outcome. "There are a lot of things I have been working on and working toward and things are hanging now. ... I probably spent too much time working and not enough campaigning," he said.
He said he had no idea what he would do now. "I wish I had some glib, creative comment. but I don't. I don't know what the future holds," he said.
Mr. Lowe's name and face became familiar after he launched a video production company and produced a TV show in Butler called "On Location with Scott Lowe" in the 1990s. He stepped into county government as a temporary chief clerk in 1996, then served as a special projects manager. He was appointed as county commissioner in July 2002 to fill the unexpired term of Joan Chew, who resigned because of health problems.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.