The battle for Butler County's chief law enforcement position is one that pits the experience of the incumbent against changes being promised by two challengers.
Three Republicans are seeking the district attorney job, which involves prosecuting all criminal cases that reach the Common Pleas Court level. The office numbers 19, including the district attorney.
While there are no Democratic candidates for the office, each of the GOP contestants is launching a write-in campaign.
They are incumbent District Attorney Randa Clark, 52, of Center; Stephen Misko, 49, of Connoquenessing Township; and Richard A. Goldinger, 37, of Penn.
Ms. Randa was appointed district attorney in January 2006, when former DA Tim McCune became a Butler County Common Pleas judge. She had been first assistant in the office since 2002, having become a prosecutor there in 1991. She was in private practice in Butler before that.
Mr. Misko worked as a police officer in San Diego, Washington, D.C., and Baltimore before becoming a federal agent for the Department of Treasury Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco and Firearms, then for the Department of Defense office of inspector general.
He got his law degree in 1990 from Duquesne University and worked in the Allegheny County district attorney's office from 1990 to 1994. He worked in a Pittsburgh commercial litigation firm until opening a private practice in Butler in 1995. He said his practice focuses on criminal defense work.
Mr. Goldinger has been in private practice since 1995. He said his practice focuses on family law, but that he also has served as a criminal defense lawyer. He is the son of Dick Goldinger, a retired county public defender.
Randa Clark
Ms. Clark, a 1972 graduate of Butler Area High School, graduated in 1976 from Thiel College, where she majored in political science. She has a master's degree in criminal justice from Youngstown State University and earned her law degree from Ohio Northern University in 1980.
She immediately opened a private practice in Butler, where, she said, she handled the gamut, from adoptions to child custody to juvenile law and criminal defense.
She became an assistant district attorney in 1991, then became first assistant in 2002 when David Hepting retired. She became district attorney in January 2006.
Ms. Clark said she hoped the public would give her a win this year because "this is my life."
She said the "race comes down to experience. You can't pretend to walk in these shoes until you've lived in these shoes."
She said she spurned some of the ideas she's heard from her challengers, saying they lack the experience to understand "how things really work around here."
"You can't say things like, 'There won't be plea bargains in certain cases,' because you can't approach this job with a blanket approach. You have to be willing to look at each case as it presents itself," she said.
She said plea agreements, which often involve a reduction in charges in exchange for a guilty plea, are tools that keep the system moving and are often necessary. "The ultimate decision as to what goes to trial and what doesn't boils down to a simple analysis of the evidence," she said.
She said some district attorneys don't make a sentence recommendation part of the plea agreement but that she didn't believe that's workable in Butler County because of the burden that would be put on the court. "Currently, we have only two judges [assigned full-time to criminal court]. I think it's helpful to the judges to give them a sentence recommendation. Ultimately, it is up to the judge," she said.
She questioned the viability of ideas that involve hiring staff. "There are some good ideas out there, but when it comes to funding them, that involves getting approval from the county commissioners, and they're trying to watch the purse strings," she said.
"The bottom line is, anyone who wants to be a DA needs to be an ADA first in this office, to understand the issues in Butler. That's why tradesmen start as apprentices and work their way up to journeymen," she contended.
Ms. Clark said her goals for a four-year term would be to expand the fatal crash reconstruction team she started in January 2006 to include first-responders. The team is now all police officers.
She intends to implement a chaplain program, which she began planning this year, calling out clergy to scenes involving death to help grieving families.
Another goal is to continue to expand education of elderly people to focus on the issues of elder abuse, identity theft and scams that target senior citizens. She has started visiting with residents of senior citizen communities this year and hopes to visit more next year.
Ms. Clark said she was looking into creating a citizens advisory board so people can meet with her and talk about their neighborhoods and their expectations for law enforcement.
Ms. Clark ran for judge in 1990 and lost to Judge Thomas Doerr.
She is a Republican committeewoman for Center and is president of the Republican Women of Butler County. She also is a founding member and current chairwoman of the Criminal Justice Advisory Board and is a member of the Prison Board, the Intermediate Punishment Programming Board, the Butler County Chiefs of Police Association, the Butler County Drug and Alcohol Board and the Fraternal Order of Police, and she serves as chairwoman of the Local Policy Board, which oversees the administration of grants that benefit clergy, law enforcement and service providers.
"This job is about more than getting convictions. It's about doing the right thing to the right person at the right time for the right reason. I've sat at the other table. I've defended people and it's made me a better prosecutor," she said.
Stephen Misko
Mr. Misko is a 1975 graduate of Good Counsel Catholic High School in Silver Spring, Md., and a 1978 graduate of the University of Maryland at College Park.
Before starting his private practice in Butler, he worked briefly for the Butler district attorney's office.
Mr. Misko said he would help the county system move more smoothly, if elected, by ensuring that an assistant district attorney be at every preliminary hearing. "Sometimes, they're there. Sometimes, they're not," he said, contending that an assistant can "screen the good cases from the bad cases and resolve a lot."
He said he would be sure that all the assistants in his office would offer their best deal during the first pretrial conference, so that there's no incentive to delaying plea agreements in the hope of getting a better offer. Ms. Clark denied there's any intent to withhold best offers, but Mr. Misko says differently.
Mr. Misko says his wide-ranging experience as a defense lawyer, a criminal prosecutor and as an investigator gives him clear perspective on how best to run a district attorney's office.
"I have seen practically everything as it relates to offenses," he said.
He pledged he would discuss all plea agreements with victims and police "not to get an agreement. That can't happen all the time, but to make sure that everyone has the information."
He pledged to seek the maximum penalty for anyone accused in a drunken-driving case that involves a death. "I will seek the mandatory on these cases," he said.
He said the widespread use of alcohol and drugs is a big problem facing Butler County because it spawns other crimes.
"I want to revamp the drug task force," he said.
He said he would centralize it and work to develop a special unit for drug forfeitures so the property of people accused of drug-related crimes would be seized. The money from the property would be funneled back into the investigations, he said.
Mr. Misko is interested in developing a confidential information pool. "I had a client who assisted in a buy of cocaine. He was given very little consideration. There needs to be a better system. The DA's office needs to give something to the informant to make it worthwhile for them to stick their necks out," he said, noting that a confidential informant pool would help get to the bottom of the drug dealing problem in the county.
He is a township supervisor in Connoquenessing, where he and his wife, Christine, are raising two children. He was elected supervisor in 2004 and has been chairman since 2005. He would give up the job if elected.
"I've learned from this job that an elected official needs an open door policy. I believe in communicating with the public. I would do that," he said.
He said his motto is "change in direction. Being a career prosecutor doesn't mean you're going to be the best DA."
Richard A. Goldinger
Mr. Goldinger, a 1988 graduate of Butler Area High School, got his bachelor's degree from the University of Pittsburgh and his law degree from the University of Akron before going into private practice in 1995 in Butler, initially with his father. He is married to Assistant Public Defender Rebecca Lozzi, who, he said, will resign her post if he is elected.
Mr. Goldinger said his private practice focuses on family law with a bit of criminal and, occasionally, some general practice. "I've done just about every aspect of the law, from handling estates and criminal defense to workers' compensation and auto accidents and slip-and-falls. You name it," he said.
He said he believed that drug trafficking in Butler County was fueling an increase in serious violent offenses. "My number one goal is to reduce violent crime by attacking the drug problem," he said.
He said he would hire more county detectives to work in a full-time drug task force that would coordinate local police departments, all in an effort to increase arrests. He said the extra costs would be covered by grants and by seizing the assets of drug dealers so they can be liquidated and the funds funneled back into the program.
He believes that anti-drug education has to be more intensive and reach younger children.
"They've got to get the message early on and we need to get that message to the influential adults in their lives, the parents and the teachers," he said. He favors community anti-drug programs based in the schools in the evening, as well as daytime school programs for the children.
He favors a special court that would be held weekly and dedicated only to defendants accused of drug offenses. It would involve intensive probation supervision with on-the-spot drug testing and review of rehabilitation efforts. "I see it as court-enforced rehabilitation," he said.
Mr. Goldinger said he believed his broad professional and life experience had helped him when it comes to discerning the "difference between a good person who makes a bad decision and a bad person." He believes in being more lenient with a first-time offender but will not plea bargain with repeat offenders.
"I will not reduce charges. You will plead to what you were charged with or go to trial and leave it to the judge," he said. He said he would not plea bargain any sentences associated with reduced charges. "I think things will run smoother that way," he said.
A major component of Mr. Goldinger's platform is what he's referring to as "openness." He promised to allow anyone who has a problem or complaint to speak to him. "I want to be available to the people. If there's a wife batterer across the street, call me. If you think the next-door neighbor is a crack house, call me. I'll see what I can do," he said.
He a Republican committeeman for Penn Township East.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.