North Allegheny is considered one of the best-performing school districts in Allegheny County, but that won't get incumbent school board members a free pass on Election Day.
While many acclaim the district's record of budget strength and test-score excellence, some wonder why financial surpluses haven't produced tax cuts. Others worry that those test ratings have become an obsession.
Five incumbents and two challengers are on the May 15 primary ballot. Five seats are available. All seven candidates have cross-filed as Democrats and Republicans.
Karen Boujoukos
Since the start of the year, Karen Boujoukos has sat on the right side of the board table, the end closest to student representatives Andy Hamm and Lily Chen.
The seating arrangement makes sense because she's often the first to report on student accomplishments, which extend beyond the classroom into the community.
Mrs. Boujoukos said the top issues facing North Allegheny are maintaining high standards for student achievement and balancing the needs of students, parents, employees and taxpayers.
"During my tenure on the board, we have seen student achievement levels increase in every national and state standard of measurement and have won numerous outstanding district awards," she said.
"I would like to continue to work for academic excellence while pursuing every possible economy of cost that will benefit our taxpayers."
Mrs. Boujoukos, 47, has lived in Franklin Park for 15 years with her husband and two sons, the youngest of whom is a high school junior at North Allegheny. She is a graduate of Tufts University and earned a master's of education from the University of Massachusetts.
Scott Cunningham
Scott Cunningham is the board member most familiar with another important choice facing voters.
A financial manager for PNC Advisors, Mr. Cunningham served on the district tax study commission, which analyzed the state-mandated Act 1 tax initiative.
He supported the panel's finding that the referendum should ask district voters whether they want to save $879 in annual property taxes by paying nearly three times more in earned income taxes, at a rate of 1.4 percent instead of 0.5 percent.
Act 1 cautions boards against taking official stands to influence voters, a warning that the district solicitor has urged the board to heed. That hasn't stopped school directors from voicing opinions on their own.
"My personal view is that we should vote no on the referendum. We are raising one tax, the earned income tax, with the promise that it will produce lower real estate taxes," he said.
Mr. Cunningham doesn't see the financial seesaw balancing out as intended.
"My expectation is that we'll get a higher earned income tax in the long run, real estate taxes will [work] themselves back up after about 18 months, and we'll end up just having higher earned income taxes."
If state officials really want to cut school property taxes, he said, they could do so by increasing the state, not the local, earned income tax. "But I don't think that's something they want to do."
The North Allegheny policy concerning property assessment appeals also has been a target of Mr. Cunningham's. He said the district's policy is unpopular and unfair, targeting new home buyers.
A board member for five years, Mr. Cunningham has a law degree from Pitt, a master's degree in public policy and management from Carnegie Mellon University and is a graduate of Penn State.
He is 48 and lives in Marshall. He and his wife have two children, who attend North Allegheny schools.
Maureen Grosheider
Maureen Grosheider is the acknowledged dean of the school board, having served for some 12 years, including a term as president.
Others might address specific topics, but Mrs. Grosheider has a reputation among her peers as being able to delineate issues from student achievement to global awareness, from budget line items to technology upgrades.
Her top concern is the costs that districts do not control, such as those for special education, transportation, charter schools and pension payments.
Mrs. Grosheider volunteered to serve on a statewide Pennsylvania School Boards Association committee that has been exploring ways to avoid a financial crisis. The defined benefits plan covering teachers and other employees is far too generous, given today's economy, she said, the payout calculated as being 2.5 percent for each year of service.
"So, if you are a teacher in Pennsylvania, and you work the normal teacher career of 35 years," she said, "you will be entitled to 87.5 percent of your final average pay."
That, she said, "is an extremely generous benefit when compared to the benefit provided by private-sector plans."
"If the state does not make some effort to correct this situation, school districts will either have to eliminate programs, staff, etc., or they will have to raise taxes. This is a train wreck waiting to happen."
Mrs. Grosheider, who declined to give her age, is a graduate of Trinity College with a master's degree in business administration from the University of Pittsburgh. She and her husband have lived in Marshall for more than 25 years and raised two children who attended North Allegheny schools.
Beth Ludwig
Beth Ludwig taught first and fifth grades for five years after earning her education degree at Penn State University. One of her enduring memories was the stint she spent student teaching in 1983 at Mill Rythe First School in England.
What made the experience so indelible, she said, was the creative energy that pervaded the open-plan school where pupils from age 4 to 11 often mixed together according to needs and interests.
She doesn't advocate classrooms without walls and grades at North Allegheny, but she sees the parallel with its creative faculty.
District teachers "definitely have much more pressure to have their students perform on numerous standardized tests," she said, but "I am confident that, at North Allegheny, we are finding a healthy balance between testing with strong results and a real love of learning."
Mrs. Ludwig also has been active as one of district's delegates to the A.W. Beattie Career Center, which hit a roadblock last week at North Allegheny. The board voted unanimously not to support the school's $24.3 million expansion project. It is unclear what next step Beattie officials will take.
Mrs. Ludwig, 45, lives in Marshall. She and her husband have three children, all of whom attend North Allegheny schools.
Karen Shaheen
Karen Shaheen is an unabashed advocate of mixing school business with Harrisburg politics.
She was recently elected to the Republican State Committee and intends to use that forum to drumbeat the need to do something statewide about one of her top district-related concerns.
"Right now, many taxpayers do not realize that we are funding a teacher's retirement package [that] includes almost 90 percent of their current pay when they retire.
"I am a big fan of our teachers, but the taxpayers cannot support that kind of retirement package."
As an active PTA parent who attends many school board meetings, Mrs. Shaheen would like to see better communication between the board and the rest of the community. As someone who has worked as an accountant at several corporations, she wants to take a closer look at the upcoming $111 million budget.
Test scores might be a priority for some families, she said, "but we still have the average student who is not receiving the same funding that the other students receive."
If elected, Mrs. Shaheen makes no secret that she would rattle a few cages.
"Most of the incumbents running for school board have continued to act as if we live in 'Pleasantville,' " she said, referring to a movie featuring idyllic suburban life, "when, in fact, we have the same problems and issues facing many other schools."
Mrs. Shaheen, 45, lives in McCandless. She and her husband have three daughters, all North Allegheny students. She has an accounting degree from Point Park University and works part time at Kress Tire Co.
Carole Shepard
Carole Shepard has seen firsthand how the current school leadership operates and she is critical that she and others haven't seen more.
A former swim team booster and member of the district strategic update committee, Ms. Shepard said the board "is lacking an urgent sense of accountability for decisions made and does not provide a reasonable degree of transparency."
She based her assessment on the years she spent on the Best Practices and Accountability Task Committee for the 2002-07 Strategic Plan. Her work on that recently concluded report led her to criticize the board for not taking certain actions sooner.
"We had recommended [faculty] position descriptions back in 2000 and they are just now writing job descriptions. It's been seven years. They should've been started in 2000."
In addition to financial restraint and technology management, her top concern is ensuring the district serves not only high-achieving students and those with special needs, but all those in between.
"We continue to refer to our quest to be within the Top 100 Schools, but I have not seen a definition I can understand or quantify," she said.
Mrs. Shepard played a prominent role two years ago during the high school swimming pool controversy, in which 26 of 40 swim team members, including her two sons, encountered breathing difficulties. The poor water and air quality were traced to an old ventilation system inadvertently forcing out the "good" air being generated by the new system.
She cited that experience as evidence that she can work with the administration toward a solution, even as she maintains a healthy wariness of its decision-making.
A speech pathologist who has worked with various school districts, Mrs. Shepard, 51, graduated from Northwestern University. She has a master's degree in speech pathology from Penn State University. She lives in McCandless with her husband and has three children, two of whom are district graduates. The youngest is a high school junior.
Alan Shuckrow
Ninety-nine times out of 100, Alan Shuckrow has been a solid backer of the board majority on positions ranging from academics to technology acquisitions. He's praised the administration for producing six months early a balanced 2007-08 preliminary budget of $111 million.
Still, the youngest school director at 38 has a hint of an independent streak. He was one of three who opposed last year's tax increase and, more recently, he opposed the board's property assessment appeals policy.
Mr. Shuckrow, like Mr. Cunningham, has been particularly outspoken about the Allegheny County property assessment system, something he probably knows more about than any of his colleagues.
He was part of the legal team at Strassburger, McKenna, Gutnick & Potter, who represented Sabre Systems Inc., which had a $23.9 million pact with Allegheny County to conduct the oft-maligned 2000 property reassessment.
In the wake of a massive wave of homeowner appeals, then-county Controller Dan Onorato withheld more than $1 million from Sabre. The resulting suit was settled three years ago with the county paying Sabre about three-quarters of that amount.
Mr. Shuckrow wouldn't be surprised if the current county system isn't overhauled again because of suits challenging the validity of using 2002 data. He'd prefer the district adopt a wait-and-see attitude about the system using the 2002 numbers because he sees it as a waste of time to challenge homeowner appeals that might eventually be upheld by the court.
"Our taxpayers are caught in the middle of things," he said, "and there's no reason that they have to be."
As for his opposition to last year's tax increase, the benefit of hindsight hasn't produced the cliche response.
"I predicted that we would not need the increase. This year, we are projecting a $3 million budget surplus," he said, "which I believe justifies my position."
One of the key issues he cited is ensuring that North Allegheny can retain its sense of community in the face of public education funding pressure as well as the changing local demographics. Franklin Park and Marshall are growing; McCandless is not.
A native of Franklin Park, Mr. Shuckrow and his wife live in McCandless. They have two children, one in first grade in North Allegheny and the other in preschool at the Western Pennsylvania School for Blind Children.
He is a graduate of Villanova University and the University of Pittsburgh law school.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.