A little more than an hour after the polls closed, campaign workers at Shawn Flaherty's headquarters realized their candidate would leave the state House of Representatives seat he had filled for the past seven months.
Mr. Flaherty, a Democrat, lost to Republican Randy Vulakovich in the 30th Legislative District, which has been represented by Republicans for more than 40 years.
Mr. Flaherty, 47, won a special election in April to fill the unexpired term of Republican Jeff Habay, who resigned after being convicted of using his office staff to do campaign work when they were supposed to be working for the state.
At the campaign office, Mr. Flaherty, his campaign staff and his family members were subdued as the votes were counted.
So was the crowd that gathered in Mr. Vulakovich's Shaler home, as they watched the returns that showed defeats by Republican U.S. Sen. Rick Santorum and the GOP candidate for governor, Lynn Swann.
They were quiet, that is, until about 10:10 p.m., when Mr. Vulakovich, 56, a retired Shaler police officer, stepped into his dining room to say that Mr. Flaherty had called to concede.
"Shawn Flaherty just called," Mr. Vulakovich said. "He said he looked at the numbers and he doesn't think he can overcome them. We're going to meet and have a transition. And I guess that's that."
But that wasn't all Mr. Vulakovich had to say. He thanked his poll workers and his campaign workers. And then, as his voice cracked from days of talking, he said, "Boy, I'm glad it's all over."
According to unofficial returns, Mr. Vulakovich got 14,712 votes to Mr. Flaherty's 12,933.
Mr. Vulakovich credited his campaign style of knocking on doors and asking friends to call their friends for support.
"Even if I had lost this election, my friendships have become stronger," he said.
The campaign had an overall kinder tone than the April campaign, in which Mr. Flaherty faced Republican Mike Dolan.
Mr. Flaherty noted the Republican registration advantage in the district, which covers Hampton, Fox Chapel and parts of O'Hara, Ross and Shaler.
"I think it boils down to it's a Republican district. It was designed to be a Republican district and it's going to go back to being a Republican district," Mr. Flaherty said. "I don't think they want a fiscally conservative Democrat."
Mr. Flaherty was pleased that he won in Fox Chapel, his home municipality, but said his plan to eliminate property taxes for schools and replace that funding with an income tax and a graduated sales tax might have been too extreme for his constituents.
He said he couldn't have fit his message with what would sell better in his district "because I couldn't believe in that."




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.