An iconic grocery store in Sewickley that earned its reputation with home delivery, employees who remembered customers' names and specialty foods that attracted shoppers from near and far, closed Friday after 80 years.
"It was time," said Marshall Morgan, 60, who began working at Select Food Market as a 10-year-old stock boy.
He took over the store from his father and now wants to do something besides spend 70 hours a week at the business.
"I don't want to be 80 years old and wish I had done this or done that," he said.
Still, the decision to close wasn't easy.
"I wouldn't have stayed this long had it been easy to leave," said Mr. Morgan, who lives in Pittsburgh. "I have a lot of friends walk through those doors every single day."
At a time when chain stores such as Starbucks, Bruegger's and Chico's have moved into the village, the loss of a long-standing, family-run market that prided itself on its uniqueness will create a void, business owners and residents said.
"It's just like a tower going down," said Betty Shields, former editor of the Sewickley Herald and a town historian. "Everyone knew Select."
It was the rare grocery store that still cut beef to order, allowed customers to buy on credit and rang each item up by hand.
The store's owners weren't simply trying to be quaint by not using bar code scanners and keeping the same pale blue checkout counters for more than 40 years.
Some of the store's workers had been there for 20 to 30 years, and the owners wanted longtime employees to build customer relationships. "We didn't want to enforce a new technology on them," Mr. Morgan said.
The announcement of the closing three weeks ago sent tremors through the weekly shopping routines of Select's devoted customers, most of whom know Mr. Morgan by name.
"So we still can't change your mind?" Michele Fedyshin, of Sewickley, asked Mr. Morgan last week during her last stop in the store.
"Should I put up a sign in the window: 'Just Kidding!' '' Mr. Morgan quipped.
Ms. Fedyshin, like every Select customer, wishes he would.
"It's part of our Saturday routine," she said. "We walk up to the village, do your dry cleaning, maybe stop at the pharmacy and bank, and then stop in Select."
In addition to the imported brie cheese, hard-to-find olive oils and crab cakes from Select's prepared foods department, Ms. Fedyshin said what kept her coming back were the people who worked there and the service.
"I could call [Mr. Morgan] and say, 'I need a roast for Friday night,' and he'd cook it for me and it'd be delicious," she said.
When Mr. Morgan's grandfather, Max, opened the business 80 years ago as a fruit store around the corner from its present location at 510 Beaver St., service like that was expected.
The town had seven other grocery stores at the time, all of them hoping to cater to the wealthy clientele of Pittsburgh industrialists who were moving up the hill to Sewickley Heights as well as the middle class in the village, and they all delivered.
Max and his son, Israel, whom everyone knew as "Izzy," eventually expanded the store to 9,000 square feet, which is small by modern supermarket standards. But whether it was building a delivery business or adding prepared foods in recent years when deliveries fell off, marketplace nimbleness is what allowed Select to be the last of the original stores left standing.
The closing of Select could be a gain for three stores in town: The Ultimate Pastry Shop, a block away, will continue to sell the locally baked breads and fresh strudel that Select carried; Safran's Supermarket, also family run, is now the only grocery store in town and already fielding requests to carry various foods Select did; and Fondi's Fish and Poultry, whose owners hope to pick up some business from Select's prepared foods department and butcher counter.
Select customers, however, said there would be no way to truly replace the store.
"It's a sad time, but I'm happy for you," Alice Valoski, a customer for three decades, told Mr. Morgan just before he locked up for the last time.
He smiled, thanked her as she left, then turned out the lights and locked the door.
"It hasn't sunk in yet," he said. "But it will. There are too many memories."




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.