In the closing days of the campaign to succeed former state Rep. Jeff Habay, it appears the clean-campaign pledge signed by Democrat Shawn Flaherty and Republican Mike Dolan has been dropped in a puddle of mud.

The candidates traded charges yesterday at a meeting with the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette editorial board and at a news conference by Mr. Flaherty.

Mr. Dolan questioned whether Mr. Flaherty properly paid taxes on a business property of which he is one-third owner. Mr. Flaherty questioned whether Mr. Dolan actually lives in the 30th House District.

Mr. Flaherty, 46, of Fox Chapel, and Mr. Dolan, 26, of O'Hara, are running in a special election next Tuesday to serve through the end of the year in the seat previously held by Mr. Habay, who resigned after he was convicted of using his office workers for campaign work on state time.

Advertise with us

Mr. Dolan also has two opponents in the May 16 primary for the GOP nomination for a full House term that begins in January, while Mr. Flaherty is unopposed for his party's nomination.

Mr. Flaherty proposed the clean-campaign pledge last month and both candidates signed it March 14. The pledge arose after Mr. Flaherty said he heard Mr. Dolan would use information about a child Mr. Flaherty fathered out of wedlock while he was separated from his wife.

Yesterday, Mr. Flaherty said the pledge "isn't worth the paper it was written on" after Mr. Dolan ran an ad about delinquent taxes on a building the Democrat owns with two partners, including Common Pleas Judge Dwayne Woodruff, his former law partner.

Mr. Flaherty said the deed recording the sale of the property to his partnership couldn't be recorded for nearly three years because of litigation and the group began paying back taxes in installments once that occurred in March 2005.

Mr. Flaherty called the television ad "misleading" and said it broke the pledge of an issue-oriented campaign without personal attacks. In a news conference at Allegheny County Democratic headquarters on the North Shore, Mr. Flaherty said the tactic was reminiscent of the conduct of Mr. Habay, who engaged in several bitter campaign battles.

Advertise with us

Mr. Dolan said the tax issue was legitimate because Mr. Flaherty has built his campaign around his expertise as a tax attorney.

"I've followed the pledge. I think this [tax issue] is relevant," Mr. Dolan said.

Although Mr. Flaherty didn't file a legal challenge to Mr. Dolan's residency -- too many other things were going on during the short campaign, he said -- he questioned whether Mr. Dolan lives in O'Hara, where he bought a home in December 2004, or outside the district in Shadyside, where he lived for several years and still owns property.

Mr. Flaherty also criticized Mr. Dolan's voting record, which shows he voted in nine of 16 elections from 1998 through 2005. That shows a "lack of maturity," he said.

Campaign spokesman Al Bowman said Mr. Dolan has lived 20 of his 26 years in the district, excluding four years while he was a student at Penn State University, and currently rents the Shadyside property to friends. He said Mr. Dolan has voted in seven of the past eight elections and credited some of the missed votes to being away at college.

Advertise with us

In addition to Mr. Flaherty's fidelity, the campaign also has raised the issue of five convictions for disorderly conduct Mr. Dolan had while a college student.

"It has gotten a little dirty out there," Mr. Dolan said.