Voters in O'Hara rejected the township's code covering the maintenance of properties, an ordinance that has been on the books but has been unenforceable because of a judge's decision in the spring.
In a "no" vote of 1,304 to 1,022, voters Tuesday determined that Ordinance 1121, the property maintenance code, shall no longer remain in effect.
Councilman Joseph Frauenholz Jr. and an ad hoc group known as Concerned Citizens of O'Hara led the opposition. They argued that the township has adequate language in the code regarding health, safety and nuisance conditions and that the revised code gave decision powers to code officials that were too broad.
"I'm pretty pleased with the way things turned out," Mr. Frauenholz said yesterday. The election also gave him a new term in his Ward 2 council seat.
O'Hara council adopted the ordinance in September 2004, with Mr. Frauenholz casting the only dissenting vote. Supporters of the revised code, led by code enforcement officer Cindy Davis and council President Robert J. Smith, argued that code officials needed the more precise language to mandate repairs and to cite owners who fail to comply.
After council adopted the ordinance, opponents gathered petition signatures seeking its repeal. When council balked, the matter wound up before Allegheny County Common Pleas Judge Joseph James, who ruled in April that the petitions were in compliance with O'Hara's Home Rule Charter and council must either repeal the code or place it on the November ballot for voters to decide.
John Santoriello was among voters who rejected the code on Tuesday. Mr. Santoriello, who has lived on Fox Chapel Road for three years, said he voted against the code because he believes the new law is not necessary. "Every time you create a new law, you make another criminal, or at least another problem."
Mr. Santoriello said he believes homeowners will maintain their properties to the extent that they are able. "I don't know what distresses these people have in their lives. I'd rather be a good neighbor than go after these people with a new law," he said.
William Boag Jr., of the township's Falconhurst neighborhood, said he also opposed the revised code. "This is about our right of ownership of private property. I don't like the idea that public officials can walk up and down the street and tell you what to do with your property. This is another example of the government feeling that they can make decisions better than ordinary citizens can."




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.