Candidates for the magisterial district judge based in Bellevue expect a close finish in the Nov. 8 election.
In a race beset by a lawsuit and recriminations, Democrat Constance G. Rankin, publisher of a Bellevue-based newspaper, is facing Republican Tara L. Smith, a former employee of outgoing District Judge Donald Presutti.
Before the primary, three former Avonworth school board members challenged Ms. Rankin's candidacy, saying she falsely represented herself on her filing papers as a practicing lawyer. She was removed from the ballot but won an appeal to be reinstated and then won the Democratic nomination in a five-way race with 723 votes to Ms. Smith's 671.
Ms. Smith received 520 Republican votes , taking that nomination. Ms. Rankin got 437 Republican votes.
Ms. Smith, of Ben Avon, currently a laboratory manager at the University of Pittsburgh, said she is campaigning down to the wire to win the judgeship.
She said she recognizes that the race will be a tough one, but she remains confident. "Even though I'm on the Republican ticket, I still have a ton of Democratic support. And I have a lot of support on the Republican side as well," she said.
Ms. Smith said that what sets her apart from Ms. Rankin is her understanding of the magisterial system. Ms. Smith has completed the monthlong Minor Judiciary Education Board Magisterial Certification course, which is state-mandated training for district judges. She added that she worked in the magisterial district judge system as an administrator for many years. "I have 17 years experience in the system. I know the administrative part of it, and my judicial background is a testament to my commitment to the community," she said.
Ms. Rankin, of Bellevue, also expects a tough fight.
"I am optimistic. I don't think it'll be an easily won election," she said.
She said her experience as a lawyer differentiates her from her opponent. "I can tell you, from practicing the law, I can spot a magistrate without a law degree in seconds. It's a critical factor for the voters to consider," she said.
"The law is too complex these days. You have to have a judge with a background in the law."
The North Boroughs is at a point in its development where it could get better or it could start sliding, Ms. Rankin said. "Having a judge who knows and understand the local ordinances will have a major impact on this community," she said.
Ms. Smith, who works part time, said if she were elected, she would be able to fully dedicate herself to the district judge position and would make the part-time judgeship a full-time post.
"I don't own another business that will deter me from my duties as district justice," she said. "Owning a newspaper and being a judge is a conflict of interest, in my opinion."
Ms. Rankin said she plans to relinquish management of the newspaper, The Citizen, if she wins the election. "Somebody is waiting as we speak to give notice and take the job," she said.
In addition to Bellevue, the district covers Avalon, Ben Avon, Ben Avon Heights, Emsworth, Kilbuck and Ohio Township.
Correction/Clarification: (Published Nov. 7, 2005)Tara L. Smith, a candidate for judge in the magisterial district based in Bellevue, is a laboratory manager at the University of Pittsburgh. Her occupation was not originally listed in this Oct. 27, 2005 story about the race.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.