The Allegheny County Democratic Committee will print 4,000 new slate cards because Harrison District Judge Carolyn Bengel has been accused of misleading the committee to gain its endorsement.

Don Walko, chairman of the party's primary campaign committee, said Bengel's name will not appear on the new cards.

He said Bengel told the county committee's office that she had been endorsed by the local Democratic committees in her district. As a result, her name was included on thousands of slate cards as a candidate endorsed by the Allegheny County Democratic Committee.

Last week, those cards were sent to voters and local committee chairpersons.

Advertise with us

One of the people who received those cards in the mail Friday was a supporter of Bengel's opponent, Maegan Susa Filo.

Filo, who knew that the four local committees had not jointly endorsed a candidate, notified her campaign consultant, Ron Brown. Brown then contacted Allegheny County Democratic Committee Executive Director Mark Salvos and later Walko.

After looking into the matter, Walko sent Brown a written explanation and apology.

In his letter, Walko stated that county Democratic committee staff members contacted local committees to find out if they had made any district judge endorsements.

In districts where no local endorsements were known, staff members called the incumbents. When Bengel was contacted, she said she was the locally endorsed candidate, Walko explained.

Advertise with us

Bengel's magisterial district includes four local Democratic committees -- Harrison, Fawn, Brackenridge and Tarentum. A candidate must receive the backing of three of those four committees to be considered the endorsed candidate.

"I was stunned to see her name on the slate," said Mary Newcomer, a member of the Tarentum Democratic Committee. "We never endorsed her," she said of Bengel.

Newcomer's committee has thrown its support behind Filo.

"I'm hopeful that the voters are smart enough to decide and choose a candidate who has lead a campaign appropriately without any stretches of the truth," Filo said.

Bengel has received the endorsement of the Brackenridge Democratic Committee, according to Filo.

Advertise with us

After the initial call from the county Democratic committee staff, Bengel was contacted by the office twice more; once to see if she wanted to be included on the slate card of endorsed candidates and one more time to make arrangements for her to pay a portion of the cost of the cards.

"When I was informed about what happened in this case I was a little disappointed about the procedure that was used," said Walko, who's chairing the primary committee for the first time.

He added, however, that staff members have customarily called incumbents to learn if they've been endorsed.

He will instruct those who received the first batch of slate cards not to use them.

Walko said he doesn't know at this point if Bengel will be asked to reimburse the committee for the cost of printing new cards or what if any sanctions the county Democratic committee can impose.

Advertise with us

"We'll have to talk to the committee's lawyer and evaluate that," Walko said. "The biggest goal now is to try to ease the injustice of what happened."

Bengel could not be reached yesterday for comment.