A Commonwealth Court ruling last week put Constance Rankin back on the May 17 primary ballot for magisterial district judge in Bellevue.

Rankin, owner of the Bellevue-based weekly newspaper, The Citizen, was removed from the ballot in March by Allegheny County Common Pleas Judge Joseph James because she listed herself on nominating petitions as an "attorney/publisher" although she hadn't practiced law for several years.

Former Avonworth school board members Jack Connors, Susan Abramowich and Elizabeth Radcliffe filed suit to have her removed from the ballot because, they argued, she had been deceptive in her campaign literature and on her nominating petition by referring to herself as an attorney.

On Friday, however, Commonwealth Court ruled that the lower court's ruling "is not supported by substantial evidence in the record. ... The election code must be liberally construed to protect a candidate's right to run for office."

Advertise with us

Connors noted that he, Abramowich and Radcliffe could appeal the ruling to the state Supreme Court, but they probably wouldn't. "I can't imagine the [state Supreme Court] judges would want to waste time on this. My guess is that time now works on [Rankin's] side, since an appeal might not be decided until after the election," he said.

Abramowich was surprised by the ruling.

"I still think we were right. I still feel that she was using the term 'attorney' to persuade people that she's more qualified and to vote for her."

Contacted after the ruling, Rankin sounded relieved.

"I hope it's over now because I am not the only candidate who has been hurt by this [lawsuit]," she said. "I had faith in the judicial system. Occasionally, errors are made, but we have a system that can correct these mistakes."