Bellevue voters Tuesday decisively approved an amendment to the borough home rule charter that clears the way for a possible consolidation of the Bellevue, Avalon, Ben Avon, Ben Avon Heights and Emsworth police departments.

The amendment, which frees the borough from its charter requirement to maintain its own, independent police department, was approved 1,634 to 668, according to unofficial returns.

"This is just the first step," Bellevue Mayor Paul Cusick said yesterday. "The second step [will be] Bellevue council calling the other municipalities to sit down and look at the options. Each community has to look at what is best for it."

He added: "This gives us the option to talk about the considerable savings and even better [police] services for Bellevue."

Advertise with us

Though 71 percent of voters supported the amendment, questions remain concerning the implementation of a consolidation plan.

Bellevue resident Kirk Sayler firmly backed the amendment, but said there could be an argument over where the combined department is placed. Still, he said, "It's long past due."

Brandy Swartzwelder, of Bellevue, found herself on the other side of the issue, but agreed that the location of the combined police department could be an issue.

"Because if something was to happen and you need someone right away, you don't want to have to worry about someone coming all the way from Emsworth all the way out to Bellevue."

She said she had occasion to appreciate the benefits of a hometown police department when her car was struck in a hit-and-run incident.

Advertise with us

"I was able to contact [Bellevue] police and they were right there and they actually caught the person. But if they would've been all the way out in Emsworth, it might have been a different situation."

Other area residents are concerned that a consolidation will dilute police coverage in each of the communities.

Denis Farrell, of Avalon, said he's not worried for himself. But, he said, there is "the older population in Bellevue and Avalon and I'm a little worried for them if they cut the police force down. It depends on which way they go as far as the strength of the force is concerned."

Many residents are optimistic, even if some questions persist.

"[Police] pretty much cross over into one another's jurisdiction all the time anyway," said George Thornton, of Bellevue, who supported the amendment. "Bellevue and Avalon are two communities like Siamese twins. They're attached at the hip."

Advertise with us

But, he said "I don't know which would be the dominant force in that. I don't know the comparative resources of the boroughs."

Mavis Rainey, of Bellevue, was more concerned with maintaining an effective police presence.

"Bellevue's not a very high crime area," said Rainey, "but the population is growing every day.

"There is certainly going to be the issue of just making sure we have enough police to police the streets of Bellevue first. So, the challenge is going to be prioritizing."