Butler County voters looking for distinctions among the three candidates vying for the seat held by retiring state Rep. Guy Travaglia will find them in their backgrounds and experiences. As for their campaign messages, each is sounding a perennial favorite: Reform the tax structure to create a better business climate so more jobs will be created.
Competing for the 11th District post are Democrat Fred Vero, Travaglio's chief of staff; Republican Brian Ellis, owner of a Butler auto dealership; and Constitution Party member and former Republican Mike Rock, a marketing department employee of Sam's Club, which is preparing to open in Butler.
Vero said he's been around the Harrisburg block and will use his savvy and experience to help constituents with everyday problems and to ensure that state dollars get to Butler.
Ellis said he'll bring his small-businessman's perspective to bear by working to make state government more cost-conscious and more business-friendly.
Rock said he'd cut his own pay, eliminate the property tax and reduce the nuisance taxes that he said are driving businesses from Pennsylvania.
The 11th District covers the Butler County communities of Buffalo, Butler, Butler Township, Chicora, Clearfield, Connoquenessing Township, Donegal, East Butler, Oakland, Summit and Winfield.
If the primary election is any indication of what's to come Nov. 2, the race could be tight. Vero captured 3,711 Democratic votes and Ellis had 3,016 Republican votes. As a third-party candidate, Rock was unable to compete but he ran in November 2000 against Travaglia, who won a fourth term in office with 76 percent of the votes cast.
Vero, 59, of Butler Township, is peddling his experience in Harrisburg to Butler County voters.
"I've been employed in the House [of Representatives] for 18 years. I know how to get things done,'' Vero said. He worked as chief of staff for former state Rep. Joe Steighner until he retired, then stayed on when the seat was taken by Travaglia in 1994.
He said he wouldn't need any time to get familiar with state government, to staff a local office or to get up to speed on the municipal concerns within his district.
Regarding Butler's financial troubles, Vero said he would first work to direct the city to any state agencies that could assist and then would be willing to draft legislation if city council was looking for state help. He also would like to open a satellite office in the southern part of his district so his staff could be closer to constituents there.
As for property tax reform, Vero said he's "very disappointed" that the new legislation directs 20 percent of gambling revenue to property tax relief, an amount he believes is too low.
Vero pledged to focus on "taking care of our businesses" by promoting tax credits. "I want to see our businesses hold on to the employees they have and better train them,'' he said.
He said he also would pressure the state to reopen the old state health center that was closed in the mid-1990s during the Ridge administration. The center had been located in Butler and had offered childhood immunizations among other services.
Vero also said he would press Rendell to release from the capital budget $3.6 million of allocated funding to finish the Saltman Run stream bank stabilization project to help with flooding in Butler's West End.
He graduated from Butler Area High School in 1963 then served in the Pennsylvania National Guard. He worked in the family's grocery store in Butler until 1977 when the business closed and Vero was elected mayor of Butler. He held the post until November 1979, when he took a job in the finance department at Pullman Standard, a position he held until the company closed in the early 1980s. He then became office manager for North Main Street Shop 'n Save, where he remained until he was hired by Steighner in September 1986.
Vero is vice chairman of the trustees of Butler County Community College, a member of the United Way board of directors, a member of the parish council of St. Peter Church and treasurer for the Pennsylvania Commission for Community Colleges. He and his wife, Deborah, a clerical worker with the state Department of Transportation in Butler, have three grown children.
Ellis, 34, of Butler Township, said he's proud he makes a living as a small businessman in his community and is not a career politician.
"I want to bring a businessman's perspective to the position,'' said Ellis who, along with his brother, owns Hansen Auto in the Lyndora section of Butler.
That businessman's perspective is what has cultivated his No. 1 goal as a state representative: "I want to make Pennsylvania a more attractive place for businesses to locate and where small business can prosper."
Ellis said some taxes must be eliminated, such as the inheritance tax. He said families are directly affected when a parent dies and passes on the business to the children, who must pay the inheritance tax. "It can put that business out of business. It's completely unfair,'' he said.
He said the state's workers' compensation program is in need of reform because the cost is out of reach for many businessmen. He also favors legislation that will allow small businesses and agriculture industry workers to come together as a consortium to buy health insurance for their employees.
"If we create a good environment for business, the jobs will come,'' Ellis said, noting that the spin-off effect would benefit such financially ailing communities as Butler. He said he does not favor the idea of a legislative bailout of the city. "If we put in place my ideas, the city wouldn't need one,'' he said.
He said property tax reform is essential, too. He said he would "never vote for a tax increase."
Ellis said he also would be a watchdog for Western Pennsylvania. "I have the sense that there's a lot of focus on Philadelphia and the eastern part of the state,'' he said, noting that educating constituents about available benefits would help.
"We need to make sure people know about programs like PACENET so those who are eligible take advantage of it,'' Ellis said of the prescription medication program for seniors. He said he favors expanding the program to make more seniors eligible and would fund it with the "windfall" from state residents switching to the new federal prescription medication program.
Ellis has never held elected office but ran against Travaglia and lost by a slender margin in 2002.
He graduated from Butler Area School District in 1988 and from the University of Pittsburgh in 1999 with a degree in communications. He is a member of Butler AM Rotary, St. Paul Church in Butler, Knights of Columbus, Big Brothers/Big Sisters, Lyndora Slovak Club and the county commissioners' drug and alcohol advisory panel. He also mentors local high school students through the YMCA Youth and Government program.
Ellis and his wife, Monica, who works with computers at II-VI Inc. in Saxonburg, have two sons, ages 5 and 3.
Rock, 33, of Butler Township, recognizes he has an uphill battle as a third-party candidate, but he believes his message is resonating with voters who are disenchanted with career politicians and "Republicans who are too moderate."
A former Republican, Rock believes the party has caved in to pressure to seek the centrist point of view. He describes himself as very conservative.
He advocates eliminating all property taxes, contending the savings associated with collecting the tax could be directed to staff coffers to make up for the lost revenues. He said a slight increase may be necessary in the sales tax to cover any shortfall.
He said he believes in accountability among elected officials and advocates a $20,000 cut in the current state representative pay of about $60,000 annually. "You can't give governments unlimited funds. They need to balance their budgets,'' Rock commented. He said he is sympathetic to financially struggling communities like Butler but the ultimate solution is to tighten the fiscal belt.
Rock said he favors the elimination of nuisance taxes that drive businesses out of the state. "We need to do all we can to encourage more business and larger employers to locate here,'' he said.
Rock graduated from Slippery Rock High School in 1989 and obtained an associates degree in 1991 from the Columbia School of Broadcasting.
He is currently employed in the marketing department at Sam's Club. He had been furloughed from AK Steel in November 2003 where he had been employed about a year. Earlier, he had worked at Eckerd Drug Store as a remodel manager for two years and had worked at Monitor Labs in Gibsonia before that. He worked briefly at a Butler radio station, as well.
Rock is a member of Liberty and Justice Association in Penn, a conservative political organization. He also is a member of the National Rifle Association. He is single and has been a member of the Constitution Party for about a year.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.