The first time they faced off last month, things were somewhat tense between Pittsburgh's two major mayoral candidates. Over the course of the campaign, however, Mayor Luke Ravenstahl and Republican challenger Mark DeSantis have grown more comfortable in each other's company.
Comfortable enough to trade compliments and criticisms in the same two-minute sound bites. The political jabs they've dealt each other during their seven debates have been framed by friendly exchanges and handshakes.
And while they might not have grown any closer, it appears that the race has.
The mood was very different at the outset, when Mr. DeSantis -- a South Side businessman and a write-in candidate -- was not perceived as having much of a chance. During a breakfast forum on business and women's issues Oct. 3 at the Duquesne Club, Mr. Ravenstahl asked that the hosts tell Mr. DeSantis, who had been invited as well, to leave the room while he spoke. Only after the mayor's speech was over was Mr. DeSantis allowed back in.
The next week, the two men stiffly squared off in a debate, a forum sponsored by the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette. There was no conversation between them beyond a polite greeting.
"I'm just happy to be in the same room when Luke Ravenstahl speaks," Mr. DeSantis said during the forum, provoking a rumbling of boos from some in the audience. The mayor did not acknowledge the remark.
But after that session, the candidates met an average of once every four days in debates sponsored by various organizations and media outlets. They became familiar with each other's answers and began anticipating arguments before they were presented.
A casualness crept into their interaction. Standing shoulder-to-shoulder at their podiums, they chuckled about running out of ties to wear in their televised appearances. "We spend so much time together," Mr. DeSantis joked.
Dr. Jerry Shuster, a professor of political communication at the University of Pittsburgh for 20 years, has monitored the race closely. His students watched the debates and have volunteered to do campaign work for both candidates.
"It appeared it was going to be more of a coronation than an election," Dr. Shuster said. "Then, all of a sudden, out of nowhere comes a candidate, Mark DeSantis, with limited or no campaign staff and probably the same in money. And this guy turns it into a mayoral race."
The keys, Dr. Shuster said, were the debates and Mr. DeSantis' presentations in media advertisements. Viewers saw him as a legitimate contender and began giving his candidacy consideration.
"He's been very effective," Dr. Shuster said, "and Republicans see him as a serious candidate rather than just a name on the ballot."
Despite Mr. Ravenstahl, 27, having the advantage of being an incumbent Democrat with all the support and financial backing that entails, Mr. DeSantis' campaign gained traction, Dr. Shuster said. And, of course, there was the matter of the mayor's ethical missteps.
"Truthfully, those things are very minor," Dr. Shuster said of such things as Mr. Ravenstahl's participation in a charity golf outing and private use of a police vehicle purchased with Homeland Security money. "But cumulative, they gave DeSantis an issue. [Mr. Ravenstahl's] youth became a question of maturity."
Mr. DeSantis, 48, used that issue in nearly every debate, pointedly noting that a mayor has to set an example.
And it was the Ravenstahl campaign, by agreeing to participate in seven debates, that provided him the forum to take those shots. Dr. Shuster called that exposure "overkill."
"Most strategists tell you that an incumbent shouldn't give his challenger any more opportunity for visibility than is absolutely necessary," Dr. Shuster said. "I would have cut it off at four [debates], and said, 'Hey, buy your own ads on TV.' "
The mayor, however, said the debates were just as vital to his campaign as they were to the challenger's.
"I thought it was [important] for the public to hear where I stand," he said. "I've never had the opportunity to run citywide before. I embraced the opportunity to debate my opponent and illustrate the differences between myself and my opponent. I'm satisfied. It gave me the opportunity to get my message out there.
"It's part of the public process, and it's for the residents of the city of Pittsburgh. This isn't about me or my opponent, it's about the future of the city, and anytime you can have a debate and a discussion about that, it's important for the voters."
There were no real surprises in the debates, unless one considers Mr. DeSantis' claim in the final meeting: "I happen to believe that I'm going to win."
Mr. DeSantis said he hadn't always been so optimistic.
"It's something I've always believed I could do, and now I believe will happen," he said.
The turning point, he said, was "the last three or four weeks." But it wasn't the debates, he said.
"People started to face the reality that they're going to have to make a voting decision," he said. "That focused people, and when Election Day gets there, it has an amazing way of focusing your attention."
Mr. DeSantis cited the newspaper endorsements he received as being a big boost. And it didn't hurt that his fund-raising began to bear fruit.
Campaign finance reports filed Friday showed the two campaigns neck-and-neck in last-minute fund-raising.
Last week Mr. Ravenstahl, a Democrat, reported $43,500 in contributions of $500 or more, and Mr. DeSantis reported $41,000 in campaign donations.
But Mr. Ravenstahl's campaign still has a decided advantage in the bank, with $548,480, versus $48,798 for Mr. DeSantis.
In the final days of a campaign, candidates must report any contributions of more than $500 to the Allegheny County Elections Division within 24 hours.
Mr. Ravenstahl has reported $10,000 campaign contributions from Henry Posner of The Hawthorne Group, William Anderson of The Anderson Group, and the Western Pennsylvania Laborers Political Action Committee.
Mr. DeSantis reported a $10,000 contribution from David Barensfeld of The Ellwood Group, and $5,000 each from the Fraternal Order of Police PAC, retired businessman John Rangos and businessman Ira Gordon.
Dr. Shuster said one of the puzzling elements to the race has been the mayor's decision not to put his message out in television and radio ads, something that his challenger has done. Upon learning that the Ravenstahl campaign planned some radio advertising for the final days, Dr. Shuster said that it suggested the race might be drawing closer than the incumbent had expected.
"For them to wait until now, to me it says, 'We won't use it unless we need to.' Now, all of a sudden, it looks like they need to," he said. "Think about it. You don't spend money you don't need to spend."
Mr. Ravenstahl said his campaign has opted for a more "grass-roots" approach, relying on yard signs, community meetings, phone banks and mailings. That doesn't mean the campaign is coasting.
"While we are confident in our polling numbers, Mayor Ravenstahl will not take anything for granted and will continue to reach out to voters until the polls close at 8 p.m. on Tuesday," said Danika Wukich, finance director for his campaign.
Whoever wins the race, Dr. Shuster said, the other man won't really be a loser. He noted that the two candidates are vying for a special two-year mayoral term triggered by the death last year of Mayor Bob O'Connor. Come Wednesday morning, he said, the winner will be working toward election to a full term of his own.
"And I wouldn't be at all surprised if the loser Tuesday is back on the ballot in 2009," he said.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.