The two major candidates for mayor -- facing each other for the seventh time in 24 days -- last night proved that familiarity doesn't necessarily breed contempt as they engaged in a debate that was not nearly as churlish as some previous encounters.

During the hour-long televised debate, sponsored by WQED-TV and the League of Women Voters, Mayor Luke Ravenstahl and challenger Mark DeSantis answered a dozen questions and traded short rebuttals that invariably stuck to the scripts they've rolled out on previous occasions.

Part of the reason for the high-mindedness might have been that the questions, posed by moderator Stacy Smith and panelists Michael Bartley, Tonia Caruso and Chris Moore, focused on how the candidates would save money, help young people find jobs and improve race relations in the city. It was the first forum during which the matter of Mr. Ravenstahl's ethics was never raised.

The candidates continued to disagree on a number of issues and their approaches to solving them, particularly the city's residency requirement for police and government workers and whether their party affiliations should impact how voters view them at the polls Tuesday.

Advertise with us

Mr. DeSantis, 48, describing himself as "a moderate, John Heinz Republican," asked voters to "take a risk" in electing the first Republican mayor in Pittsburgh in generations. He also said he expected to have Democrats working in his administration "because, after all, most of the city residents are Democrats."

"The key is, I'm going to find the most talented people I possibly can," he said. "I'm going to bring forward ideas that work. I'm not going to worry about what philosophy they derive from or whether they're Republican or Democratic solutions. I'm going to worry about whether these solutions work."

Mr. Ravenstahl, 27, echoing points his campaign has made in recent mailings, countered that Mr. DeSantis, as a Republican, has supported candidates and administrations that have hurt Pittsburgh.

"The policies of Rick Santorum and George Bush aren't in line with the Democratic voters of Pittsburgh," Mr. Ravenstahl said. "We see where the federal government has left urban America."

"Here we are talking about George Bush again," Mr. DeSantis said. "You continue to talk about President Bush when you don't have anything to say. ... We should focus on [Pittsburgh] and not worry about what is happening in Washington."

Advertise with us

"I'm very concerned about what's happening in Washington," Mr. Ravenstahl responded. "And I think my opponent should, too."

"Then you should go work there," Mr. DeSantis shot back. "I'm concerned about what's happening in Pittsburgh."

Mr. Ravenstahl also faulted Mr. DeSantis for promising he would increase police presence in neighborhoods while saying he would lift the city's longtime residency requirement.

"I couldn't disagree more," the mayor said. "How much of a vested interest is a police officer going to have if he or she drives into the city, works for eight hours, then drives back out to a suburban community? It doesn't make sense and it doesn't work."

Both candidates, when asked about their management styles, cited their business degrees and experience. Mr. Ravenstahl described himself as an inclusive, "hands-on" manager, who during his 13 months as mayor has sought out city employees and listened to their suggestions and concerns.

Advertise with us

Mr. DeSantis stressed his business experience as an entrepreneur who has been "creating them from scratch."

"Many of the businesses that I've been involved in or a part of ... were started over a beer with two colleagues," he said. "Having the experience of creating a business is something that everybody in government should have."

Correction/Clarification: (Published Nov. 4, 2007) This story as originally published in Nov. 2, 2007 editions about the mayoral debate on Nov. 1, 2007 failed to include the League of Women Voters as a sponsor of the event.