For the first time in her life, Cindy Perseo was able to vote by herself yesterday.
Ms. Perseo, 54, of Squirrel Hill, is unable to read a standard ballot because she is blind. Yesterday, an Election Systems & Software voting machine that Allegheny County purchased to comply with the Help America Vote Act read the candidates' names to her.
It wasn't a quick process, but it was liberating for Ms. Perseo, who has been blind since birth.
She was one of 60 people who were trained yesterday at the Three Rivers Center for Independent Living in Wilkinsburg to use the new voting machines, which have features designed to comply with the Americans With Disabilities Act. The county began using the new machines last year and conducted the training to increase participation among disabled voters, who traditionally have very low turnout rates.
The machines did not exactly receive rave reviews.
"It has its goods and its bads," said John Barron, 30, of Natrona Heights.
Mr. Barron, who owns a consulting firm on accessibility with his friend and housemate Dan Shirey, 26, said the problem with the voting machine for both men is that they have limited use of their hands, so reaching the screen to vote is difficult. However, if technicians are available to bring the machine down to them, they can use it.
Mr. Barron said he would not use the 18-inch-long mouth stick made available as a possible aid.
"I won't put anything in my mouth except food," he said. "I tried the poking things before."
Mr. Shirey, who was unable to reach high enough to push the button to record his vote, also is unable to use the mouth stick. The stick has replaceable bite pads that are changed with each user.
The button at the very top of the machine, used to finalize votes, was a common problem in the room.
"I could reach it, but it wasn't easy," said Rob Oliver, 35, of White Oak. Mr. Oliver has limited use of his hands after a body surfing accident left him mostly paralyzed 15 years ago.
Gary John, 44, of Wilmerding, who uses an eye-driven Dynavox computer to speak and has severely limited ability to use his hands, had to vote on the new machine the same way he would have on the old machine, by nodding when a helper, in this case one of the trainers on the system, Lawrence Reed of Point Breeze, chose the correct candidate.
"It's not user-friendly in all cases," Mr. Reed said, but he was able to discern the candidate for whom Mr. John wanted to vote. Mr. John said after the training that he is now likely to vote, something he has never done.
Jong Bea Kim, a postdoctoral fellow in rehabilitation technology at the University of Pittsburgh, tried the mouth stick from his wheelchair.
Mr. Kim, who has control of his head motions, pulled his chair in close to the machine and was able to type in write-in votes and vote for individual candidates, but when the time came to record the ballot, the stick would not reach the top of the machine.
He said some sort of switch system would work better. Paul O'Hanlon of the Disabilities Law Project said sip-and-puff technology also works better than the mouth stick.
Bill Newland, 62, of Shaler, who is blind, said he found the machine instructions too wordy, leaving him impatient to vote.
He said he had no problem using the buttons that were built into the bottom of the machine to vote.
But Gayle Block, 50, of Squirrel Hill, who is blind, complained about the buttons, saying they needed to be more prominently raised so she could find them more easily.
"It certainly will take me a while to vote, especially if there are a lot of write-ins." she said. For blind voters to write in names, they have to wait as the machine scrolls through the entire alphabet until it gets to the letter they want.
Karen Simpson, the project manager for the Elections Bureau who is in charge of implementing the system, said the session allowed the 13 trainers to see what the community needs.
"We had to learn to hold back," she said, explaining that people who are helping want to jump in when they aren't really needed.
Ms. Block, who has been legally blind since a stroke, had complaints about the volume of the machine and the buttons, but no complaints about being able to cast her own ballot.
"When I'm in the booth, I like it to just be me."





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.