It was close, but in the end incumbent state Rep. Joseph Preston, D-East Liberty, avoided the oust-incumbents sentiment and won his party's nomination for a 13th term.

Mr. Preston defeated community activist Ed Gainey by 96 votes -- 3,253 for Mr. Preston to 3,157 for Mr. Gainey -- in final, unofficial results.

Across the state, 15 of Mr. Preston's fellow House incumbents weren't as fortunate as they lost their party's nomination for re-election, most because of last summer's controversial legislative pay raises. Only two incumbents lost in the state Senate, but they were two big ones, President Pro Tem Robert Jubelirer, R-Altoona, and Majority Leader David Brightbill, R-Lebanon.

"It wasn't easy," Mr. Preston said yesterday. "When you consider this guy has been running for two years and we were running for three weeks, I think we did all right. Of course, we could have done better, but we did all right."

Advertise with us

Mr. Preston was referring to two years ago, when Mr. Gainey was removed from the ballot by a judge for having improper signatures on campaign petitions when he tried to challenge Mr. Preston. He had made no secret of his interest in winning the seat since then.

Mr. Preston said he thought he wasn't swept up in the anger over the pay raises because of his long record of service to the district.

Although the results are unofficial, Mr. Preston said they are unlikely to change because of Allegheny County's new electronic voting machines. With the lever machines used in previous years, it was easy for poll workers to misread numbers on election night and have errors corrected in the official count, but now the results are read electronically, which should mean fewer human errors.

Absentee ballots haven't been counted yet, but it is unlikely there would be a large amount for either candidate.

Mr. Gainey, a community activist and former aide to former Pittsburgh Mayor Tom Murphy, could not be reached for comment.

Advertise with us

No Republican filed in the district.

Statewide, 15 House incumbents lost yesterday -- 11 Republicans and four Democrats.

In the five-county area, four incumbents lost their party's nomination. They were Frank Pistella, D-Bloomfield, a 28-year incumbent; Ken Ruffing, D-West Mifflin, seeking his fourth term; Tom Stevenson, R-Mt. Lebanon, finishing his fifth term; and Frank LaGrotta, D-Ellwood City, who has been in office since 1987.

Other incumbents who lost, based on unofficial returns, were Teresa Forcier, R-Crawford; Patrick Fleagle, R-Franklin; Stephen Maitland, R-Adams; Roy Baldwin, R-Lancaster; Gibson C. Armstrong, R-Lancaster; Peter Zug, R-Lebanon; Bob Allen, R-Schuylkill; Dennis Leh, R-Berks; Sue Cornell, R-Montgomery; Paul Semmel, R-Berks; and Fred Belardi, D-Lackawanna.