Dear Santa letters

Each of us has a story. This one made our website. To suggest someone for the Us column, email Uscolumn@post-gazette.com.

Have you ever written a letter to Santa Claus?

Leslie Medice did 45 years ago, growing up in Dayton, Ohio.

“I wrote letters. I was always asking for things,” the Mt. Lebanon woman recalls. “I never got a reply.”

Advertise with us

So now she writes replies, as Santa. By Sunday afternoon, she had written 180 letters to children she will never meet. Most of the recipients are local, but she also has written letters to believers in New Jersey, Vermont, Tennessee, Texas and Washington state.

Three weeks ago, Leslie offered on two Facebook groups to reply to any Dear Santa letters she received. She explained that she was an empty nester who was organized and ready for Christmas.

“I didn’t know if I would get eight letters or 800,” she says.

Just in case it was a lot, she left a note for her mail carrier: “Hi Andy, I am going to be getting letters addressed to Santa....”

And they began to fill her mailbox, five to 10 a day. She got 24 letters at once from a kindergarten class at a local elementary school. She’s not sure which one, but she’s pretty sure its students are diverse.

Advertise with us

One boy asked Santa for a Nintendo Switch game console, which retails for $299. A girl in the same class asked for a Christmas tree since her family didn’t have one. Leslie tears up when she tells that story.

“Their letters came in a group, with the teacher’s address. If only I had her address, she would have a Christmas tree today!” she says.

The letters’ pace picked up when Leslie was featured on the front page of the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette on Dec. 7. That’s when she — or Santa — began hearing from other parts of the country.

When I and Post-Gazette photographer Lake Fong visited her last week at her house with a red front door, Leslie showed us some of the letters. She spread them out on a desk in her office next to the chaise longue where she does most of her writing on two types of Santa stationery with a red pen — Santa’s favorite color.

My favorites were the kindergartners’ letters on ruled paper with crayon drawings of jolly Santas and extra fat lines for beginning writers. I could almost see the kids carefully forming lowercase letters that barely brushed the dotted lines in the middle of each line. The letters followed a formula:

Advertise with us

“Dear Santa, I have been good. I want a ….” LOL doll, Beyblades, Matchbox cars, a basketball, Legos, etc.

Since my boys, like Leslie’s two sons, are now in their 20s, I had to ask what those first two toys were. I found out that LOL dolls come hidden inside layered balls and that Beyblades are like the Battling Tops I had as a kid. I didn’t want that game as much as Electric Football, but Battling Tops turned out to be a lot more fun. I was much harder to bring down as Hurricane Hank than as the white plastic running back who never followed his blocks. He mostly rumbled in lazy circles.

The Internet has helped Leslie respond knowledgeably to the kids’ requests. She makes no promises since she’s not sure whether Santa can accommodate them.

“If they ask for something big, I say, ‘Oh, isn’t that fun!’”

In her Santa letters, Leslie often compliments the children on their neat printing and tells them about Mrs. Claus baking and the reindeer playing games. Sometimes she says that Santa has been watching them. A few of the letter writers talk about their friends at school.

Advertise with us

“I say I’ve been peeking in your classroom window and I’ve noticed you’ve been so kind to your friends,’” Leslie says.

With each reply, she encloses a small bag of red and green glitter — Magic Santa Dust. She tells them to sprinkle it on their driveway on Christmas Eve, “so when the moon shines, I’ll be able to find your house more easily.”

A boy named William wrote that he had found Donner, Blitzen and Prancer in his neighbor’s yard. “I said I appreciated him sending them back.”

Leslie’s friends have offered to help out with the letters but she has turned them down. She is grateful for the “elves” who leave Santa postage stamps in her mailbox.

The children’s letters have brought back a little of the Christmas magic that filled the Medice house when Alec, 23, and Binny, 20, were little. She loves to show Santa’s mail to her boys and her husband, Mark.

Advertise with us

“I’m getting more out of it than I’m giving,” she says. “I’m almost like the Grinch. My heart is growing!”

Your heart was never “two sizes too small,” Leslie. But I bet it’s stronger than your wrist about now.

She’s not worried about writer’s cramp, she says. She’s got 11 months to recover.

“This is my new holiday tradition!”

Kevin Kirkland: kkirkland@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1978.