Each of us has a story. This one made the website. To suggest someone, email uscolumn@post-gazette.com.
Fake news causes real problems.
Perry Bergman holds a Ph.D. in chemical engineering and was part of the United States delegation at the 1997 Kyoto Protocol meetings in Japan, given his expertise in climate-change science.
But against his wife’s advice, he shared his concern about what he described as “censorship” by reputable news organizations while proclaiming science news reporting to be “a disaster.”
(Ouch! I’m a health and science reporter. But I continued smiling.)
“We need to check the facts of the fact checkers,” proclaimed Mr. Bergman, 79, of Mt. Lebanon, before proclaiming NPR to be a “terrible” network. The network, he said, describes immigrants as undocumented rather than what he deems factual — “illegal.”
Read More
“That’s like calling a drug dealer an undocumented pharmacist,” he said.
Bob Snyder, 79, said the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette is a second-tier newspaper and would benefit from synergy with The Wall Street Journal, which he described as a first-tier newspaper. (I’m still smiling, but, like a defensive lineman, hiding the pain from the cross block.)
The Bethel Park man with an engineering degree had a long career in business and now helps merchants with credit-card processing fees.
“When Walter Cronkite spoke, it was the gospel,” he said. “But now we don’t know we’re being deceived. We’re in a position where we have to verify everything everyone says, and I don’t see us moving into the future and having to verify everything.”
Then there’s Stephanie Edwards, 29, of Brookline, a “pretty jaded” charter-school health teacher but a big fan of and contributor to NPR, even if she “doesn’t always agree with what they’re saying.” (I decided against introducing her to Mr. Bergman.) One of her tasks, she said, is teaching children to read news and make sure it’s accurate.
“I see every day a pervasive, divisive role of fake news that’s driving a wedge between people who have the opportunity to get along and make the world a better place but focus on little things rather than big issues — the negative rather than the positive,” she said.
This was no cage match over NPR, the Post-Gazette, or any other news outlet. The focus here was the aforementioned fake news — Pulitzer-Prize-winning journalism vs fantastical click-bait and everything in-between.
The three were among the 40 people attending the “Fake News and Information Literacy Workshop” on Wednesday in the belly of the Mt. Lebanon Public Library. Their comments revealed confusion, concern and frustration generated by the many issues surrounding fake news.
Mila Sanina, executive director of the nonprofit newsroom PublicSource, spent nearly two hours schooling everyone about distinguishing fact from fakery — a difficult task.
Future workshops, sponsored by the Allegheny County Library Association and PublicSource, are scheduled for 6:30 p.m. Sept. 19 at the Sewickley Public Library (for teens); 7 p.m. Sept. 24 at the Monroeville Public Library (adults and teens); 6:30 p.m. Oct. 1 at the Sewickley Library (adults); and 3:30 p.m. Oct. 21 at the Mt. Lebanon Library (teens). Additional information is available at publicsource.org.
Fake news sites don’t carry big red dots or “Truth” slashed with a diagonal line. Were it so easy.
Wikipedia lists 74 fake news sites, including the Boston Tribune, NBCNews.com.co and washingtonpost.com.co, that market conspiracy theories, proclaim that live celebrities are dead and mass killings are hoaxes.
“In these workshops, I try to emphasize how important critical thinking is — that the internet is NOT a source,” Ms. Sanina said. “There are websites and news organizations that provide good information and have protocols. It’s good to be aware of where you are on the internet.”
Facebook represents a major platform where fake news is shared.
Determine the news source and who said what. Reputable fact-checking websites include snopes.com and online applications like factitious.augamestudio.com where children can test their ability to detect fake news, she said.
And if it sounds false, it probably is. Check whether reputable news sources covered the same story. Remember, some fake news sites use real stories as stems on which they add fictitious fruit.
Ms. Sanina also stressed the need to teach children and teenagers the importance of news and how to separate fact from fiction. Their parents likely no longer read newspapers but pore over their smartphones. The socializing aspects of news consumption is lost.
“It takes initiative, time and effort, and people don’t want to take on the responsibility. The onus is on us, as much as people don’t want to hear it,” Ms. Sanina said. “By sharing and clicking on fake news, you are reinforcing unhealthy fake news production.”
So attend a workshop. Ms. Sanina and others will equip you with news-reading tools.
She recommends thinking before believing. Researching before sharing.
Otherwise, by sharing fake news — “by shedding the light,” as she says — “you let the weeds grow.”
David Templeton: dtempleton@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1578. Twitter: @templetoons.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.