Each of us has a story. This one made our website. To suggest someone for the Us column, which runs every Monday, email Uscolumn@post-gazette.com.
For more than 25 years, an angel stood by Ed Graf’s shoulder as he enjoyed cocktails with his friends. And by his other shoulder was … another angel.
No devils in The Priory, the former Catholic church and monastery on the North Side that Ed and Mary Ann Graf turned into a hotel and reception space. A few rowdy guests, maybe, but they never met the two child-sized angel statues in the choir loft.
Their wooden faces are serene and they hold symbols of Christ’s Passion — a crown of thorns and Veronica’s veil, imprinted with Jesus’ face. Since the 1870s, the angels had stood in the company of saints down below, at St. Mary’s Church. Shortly after the Grafs bought the old church in 1984, they auctioned off the other statues and moved the angels to the choir loft, where they remained — until two weeks ago.
Historic angel statues from the Priory Hotel donated to Diocese of Covington
Ed Graf is in his 80s now, and has trouble climbing the stairs to the loft. “He’s ready to let them go,” said his son John, president of The Priory. Jordan Hainsey was ecstatic. “May God be praised,” he wrote in an email.
Jordan, 31, is a deacon who will be ordained a priest next May. When he first saw the statues six years ago, he was working in the art gallery of his alma mater, Saint Vincent College in Latrobe. He and Brother Nathan Cochran were finishing an exhibition about Brother Cosmas Wolf, a 19th-century German monk who hand-carved statues and altars for churches across the Midwest. Jordan and Brother Nathan hoped that the Grafs would one day donate the angels to Saint Vincent’s, where Brother Cosmas lived, worked and died in 1894.
Brother Nathan passed away in July 2014, five months after I met him while writing about the exhibition. Jordan would be the one to bring the angels home, and I wanted to help.
I have long had a fondness for angels and monks. The nuns at St. Benedict’s School in Buffalo, N.Y., told us to leave room on our seats for our guardian angels, and tipsy monks were the theme of my cousins’ German restaurant. I grew up believing the smiling monk in one print was one of my great-uncles, who smoked fat cigars at family picnics.
But I felt unworthy at The Priory that August afternoon. When I was growing up, a plaque bearing a blessing and a photo of Pope Paul VI hung in our living room. By the time I was a senior at an all-boys Catholic high school, the plaque was stored in a cabinet. I found it there one night while looking for something hard to bounce quarters on.
For the uninitiated, quarters is a drinking game whose object is to bounce a quarter into a glass of beer. If you succeed, you designate someone to drink it. If you miss, you drink.
Yes, I know it’s sacrilegious, and no, I never mentioned it in confession. My friends and I used The Pope a half-dozen times before my mother found out and hid it. But it was too late; a picture of the plaque with a quarter and glass of beer appeared in the 1985 St. Joseph’s Collegiate Institute yearbook.
When I arrived at The Priory, I discovered the angels had already made their descent into the Grand Hall at the Priory, ready to be loaded into the Hainseys’ silver Jeep Cherokee.
Jordan, who grew up in Hollidaysburg, told John and me the statues were probably carved from oak or chestnut and were fully done (sometimes the backs were left unfinished). “Cosmas certainly spent a lot of time with these,” he said.
He pointed out original colors peeking from beneath fading pink and light blue paint. A Cincinnati restorer would carefully strip and repaint them, he said, at a total cost of about $4,000.
Then Jordan detailed his idea for the angels’ final destination. He is assigned to St. Augustine, a church in Covington, Ky., that is about the same age as The Priory. It’s blocks away from the warehouse where Brother Cosmas and other artists created statues and other liturgical items in the 1860s.
Jordan plans to place the restored angels in the sanctuary as part of a major renovation. John loved the idea.
“It’s a bittersweet moment,” he said. “They’re the last vestige of the church. But they’re going to a great home, and that’s really gratifying.”
Jordan was reminded of something Brother Nathan said while searching for Cosmas’ sacred works. Most of his altars were painted white or discarded in the 1960s.
“Brother Nathan always said it was immigrants who paid for these things.”
He looked directly into the angels’ passive faces. “They are going back to the people who paid for them.”
Jordan and I each lifted a statue, surprised they weighed only about 35 pounds. As he shifted his angel over to make room for mine in the back of the car, I suddenly felt lighter, basking in the smiles of monks shining down upon us. I swear I could smell a cigar.
Kevin Kirkland: kkirkland@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1978.







Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.