Matthew Falcone, president of Preservation Pittsburgh, lives in Deutschtown on the North Side, but he digs for history all over the city. As a member of the city’s Historic Review Commission, he has researched 20 sites to nominate as landmarks.
Today, we inaugurate a recurring feature about Pittsburgh place histories in Deutschtown with Mr. Falcone as our guide, knowing that whatever neighborhood he picks, he will likely show us a place we only thought we knew.
East of Allegheny Commons Park, Deutschtown was riven by the construction of Interstate 279 North in the late 1980s.
As preservation buffs know too well, thousands of historically significant and beautiful buildings have been felled by wrecking balls throughout this city’s history. Even though many sites don’t have historic markers, no one can erase the fact the buildings were there. And if they were there, they are part of the story.

It just takes some digging to find them.
The identity of one such place might surprise you, so please join us as we proceed from Arnold’s Tea, our meeting point on East Ohio Street. We walk up to Foreland Street then several blocks toward I-279. When the North Side was Allegheny City, before 1907, Foreland was First Street.
Here we are, beside the parking lot of the Croatian National Hall, where Foreland meets East Street. Matthew pulls a photocopy of a Hopkins map from his satchel. The little square on the corner of First and East is labeled “synagogue.”
Beth Israel. Now a surface parking lot.

“When I first moved here and started looking at old maps, this was a tip that Jewish people had lived around here,” Matthew says.
The Rauh Archives at the Heinz History Center has been working on a podcast about Jewish history in Western Pennsylvania, and one episode is on the Beth Israel congregation, said Eric Lidji, director of the archive.
Beth Israel established in the 1890s and started building its congregation in people’s homes, Mr. Lidji said. The congregation formally disbanded in 1969, he said.
Deutschtown touts its German heritage, thus its moniker, and one of its murals shows heraldic German flags. But there were many Swiss immigrants, and Jews who had come not only from Germany, but Austria, Hungary, Poland and Russia. You would never know by inspecting the neighborhood that Deutschtown has Jewish stories to tell, except by a marker we will visit near the end of the tour.
For our next stop, we walk to Shawano Way, an alley north of Foreland, where we stand looking at a concrete wall. Our guide takes a book from his satchel.
“There used to be a barn here, and it’s where Commando Kelly grew up,” he says, showing us a copy of “One Man’s War,” Sgt. Charles E. Kelly’s autobiography. “With nine brothers living above a barn and no heat or plumbing.”
Kelly went down in history for his one-man barrage during World War II in holding off German forces from a house in an Italian village, covering for the rest of his unit as it evacuated, using a Browning Automatic Rifle, a Tommy gun, a bazooka, a 1903 Springfield rifle from World War I, a carbine, an M-1, a 37 mm anti-tank gun, a phosphorus grenade, mortar shells as improvised grenades and a rocket launcher. He was the last man out.
His heroic deed earned him a Medal of Honor, fortune, fame and celebratory parades, but his life spiraled after his young wife died of cancer. He bounced around the North Side, at one point renting on Lockhart Street.

We are headed there now, to look at a row of five three-story, Richardsonian Romanesque townhouses built together in 1888.
“Disclaimer,” Mr. Falcone says when he points to where Kelly lived. “It’s my house.”
The houses were rentals for most of a century, and renters are not considered in most histories, largely because their names are not on legal documents and there is an assumption that important people don’t rent.
For that reason, Mr. Falcone said, it took a lot of digging to unlock the unknown stories of that row. He credits the late Carol Peterson, a property researcher and fellow member of the Historic Review Commission, with helping him establish the importance, on a national level, of the people who lived in that row.
One early tenant was a member of the Kaufmanns — the department store and Fallingwater family. Another was Pauline Hanauer Rosenberg, a founder of the National Council of Jewish Women who served as the Pittsburgh chapter’s first president. She helped found the Irene Kaufmann Settlement House in the Hill District and traveled to advocate for women’s rights, including the right to vote.
Another: Rabbi Lippman Mayer of the Rodef Shalom congregation and a founder of Reform Judaism.

Which leads to our last stop in Deutschtown, on Stockton Avenue — the Pittsburgh Platform state marker. It was installed near the site of the Concordia Club, a Jewish social center where, in 1885, at Mayer’s invitation, 18 rabbis from around the country hammered out the document that established Reform Judaism in the United States.
Matthew opens a book of Allegheny City history to the page that shows the Concordia Club, a Richardsonian Romanesque that resembled the Allegheny County Courthouse. On its footprint now are a Mercy Behavioral Health clinic, circa the 1960s, and a lawn beside the city’s Sue Murray pool.
The club relocated to Oakland, and by 1907, the year Pittsburgh annexed Allegheny City, Rodef Shalom did too. It had outgrown its synagogue on Eighth Street, Downtown, and sold it to a Presbyterian congregation.
Before we end our tour, let’s make a side trip Downtown for a stop on Eighth Street just to look at another surface parking lot and imagine a grand building on the site, an easy walk from Rabbi Mayer’s Lockhart Street home.
Diana Nelson Jones: djones@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1626. Twitter@dnelsonjones.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.