"Digging History" is a recurring feature in which Matthew Falcone, president of Preservation Pittsburgh and a member of the city’s Historic Review Commission, guides us on historical tours of places we only thought we knew.
•
When I asked Matthew Falcone to partner with me on a regular series of tours, for which he would dig into the history of a place and share it with all of us, I gave him one directive: Surprise us.
We started our series in April, in the North Side’s Deutschtown, where he revealed historical details about the Jewish history there. From the responses I got from readers, he surprised most of you as much as he did me.
It’s a bold man who picks perhaps the best known of Pittsburgh’s neighborhoods for our second Digging History mystery tour — the Strip District.
When we set a date, he emailed the rendezvous: “Let’s meet at Lucky’s.”
Read More
Lucky’s is the popular name of the Real Luck Cafe, a bar at 1519 Penn Ave. with a shamrock emblem hanging from its facade. But its decorative window hoods and cornices, stained-glass windows above the doors and storefront windows, including a transom with a little vent that swings open, are clues that it was built to be something a little more highbrow than a bar.
Digging History
A plaque on the building makes this playful claim: “On this site in 1897, nothing happened.”
When you dig history as much as Mr. Falcone does, such a claim is a challenge.
“I found an article from 1897 about a bogus priest who was working the Strip District. He dressed like a priest and asked people to lend him valuables, jewelry, watches, for a parish fair at a church in Turtle Creek. He was really a grifter.”
Gabriel Weisser owned Weisser’s Jewelers — Lucky’s first use, starting in the 1870s. The Weisser family lived above the store. Maybe this grifter hit him up for a donation and a little red flag went up.
“Gabriel Weisser visited the church in Turtle Creek, and nobody had heard of that priest. So he cracked the case.”
Weisser’s Jewelers was built when Penn Avenue through the Strip District was a full-service neighborhood corridor. The marketplace that today defines the Strip had not expanded past the warehouses and terminal buildings along the Allegheny River and the railroads, where it was a wholesale food hub.
Lucky’s today is the only building of its vintage in the block. It was altered only with the replacement of storefront windows with glass block, probably in the 1930s.
“The interesting thing about the Strip, and all over Pittsburgh at one time, was that there would be a warehouse beside a store like this, or even a house,” Mr. Falcone said.
Our next stop: a vacant lot at 16th and Penn.
“This was the site of the first public bathhouse in Pittsburgh,” he said. “It was established by a civic club that worked to alleviate the issues of people in poverty. You would walk in and for 5 cents get a bar of soap and a towel and take a bath or a shower.”
He pulled a photo from his pack showing men waiting in the lobby — blacks and whites, old and young. The bathhouse was so popular that it had to be replaced by a bigger one several years after it was built in 1897.
We will get to it later.
The surprise of the day is a building so well disguised that few people would guess what it was built to be. It looks like a barn or a warehouse. At 17th and Penn, across from Wholey’s, it most recently was a discount produce market, now vacant.
“Its origins as the Fourth United Presbyterian Church date to the Civil War or before,” Mr. Falcone said. Around the side, parging is coming off in chunks. The top half is covered with vinyl siding.
When the Fort Pitt Candy Co. was demolished, this building became the Strip District’s oldest, he said. It was one of four churches within two blocks of each other — St. Elizabeth’s, now the Orchard Hill Church and before that the Altar Bar; St. Philomena, which is gone; and St. Patrick’s at 17th Street and Liberty Avenue.
During the Great Depression, St. Patrick’s was the church of Father James Cox. His radio ministry reached a national audience, and he advocated for the wretched souls in a shantytown nearby.

In 1931, Father Cox organized 15,000 men, called Cox’s Jobless Army, for a march on Washington.
Jobless men weren’t the only people who crowded into the new bathhouse at 1906-08 Penn Ave. The New People’s Bathhouse doubled the size of the previous one and added a floor for women and children.
“It was so successful that it paid for its construction within a year,” Mr. Falcone said.
At street’s-eye level, the building, which today houses Little Bangkok Restaurant, the General Merchandise Outlet and a tattoo parlor, is a hodge-podge of doorways, but if you stand back and look up, you see one large handsome building, designed by architect William James Carpenter.
The historic photo Mr. Falcone pulled from his pack shows a door with an elaborate pediment where Little Bangkok’s utilitarian doorway is. The brickwork to the right of the door bears a trace of an arch, a clue of past use.
Mr. Falcone said that the light wells at the base of the building are another possible clue: Was there a pool in the basement?
“The Strip District is filled with these little clues,” he said. “In some cases, the clue is the building itself.”
Diana Nelson Jones: djones@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1626. Twitter@dnelsonjones.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.