Frederick Gross of "the Evans City-Zelieople area," focuses his passion for history on the Revolutionary War; Civil War; Seven Years War and local history, he said. He asked  the question about George Washington's reference to “Murdering Town” that inspired this story for The Neighborhood. "I have always lived in the area that Washington passed through on his way to Ft Leboeuf," Mr. Gross said in an email. "Washington stayed at Murthering(Murdering) Town on his way north. Although I have seen various references to the location no one sees to know the exact location or reason for the name."

It sounds like a young adult horror novel, or the name of the next hot Netflix documentary. But Murdering Town is a real(ish) place, marked on a map of the area by George Washington on his 1753 swing through Western Pennsylvania.

Reader Fred Gross, curious about history, asked The Neighborhood team for help in finding it with the question: “Can you find the location of Murthing or Murdering Town in the Harmony Evans City area ( circa 1750)? George Washington visited there.”

So do we know where Murdering Town was?

Advertise with us

Enter The Neighborhood for more like this

“The short answer is no,” said Rodney Gasch, president and CEO of Historic Harmony, which operates the Harmony Museum. “If you really want to get a sense of Murdering Town, get five historians in the same room and it might eventually lead to murdering.”

The only description of the town in recorded history comes in journals from George Washington and his guide, Christopher Gist. Washington, then 21 years old, had been sent by Virginia lieutenant governor Robert Dinwiddie to make contact with the French and demand that they withdraw from the Ohio Valley, which was also claimed by the British.

They first encountered Murdering Town on Nov. 30, 1753, on their way to meet the French. Washington doesn’t mention that visit at all in his journal, while Gist refers to it simply as a settlement on a branch of the Great Beaver Creek, where they acquired corn and dried meat.

This painting by Daniel Huntington, titled "George Washington and Christopher Gist Crossing the Allegheny River," was part of "An American Odyssey: The Warner Collection of American Painting" at the Frick Art Museum. (Courtesy of The Warner Foundation and Warner Collection of American Art)

Washington and his crew made it to meet the French at Fort LeBoeuf, near Waterford, Pa., where French commander Jacques Legardeur de Saint-Pierre politely informed him that the French would not be abandoning their territory.

Advertise with us

In a hurry to get back to deliver the message to Lt. Gov. Dinwiddie, Washington and Gist decided to let their weary horses and other members of their party rest, and to carry on to Virginia on foot.

They traveled what Washington describes as about 30 miles from Logstown — now Ambridge — and came upon what Washington refers to in his journals as “Murdering Town” and Gist calls “Murthering Town” — a Native American settlement. Why the difference in the names? Mr. Gasch doesn’t know, but wonders if perhaps Gist’s journal was smudged.

In Murdering Town, they met a young Native American who Gist believed that he recognized. Gist had seen him earlier in the journey, at the large trading post in Venango, which is now Franklin. “This fellow called me by my Indian name, and pretended to be glad to see me,” wrote Gist. The young man offered to serve as their guide and Washington readily accepted, wrote Gist. But after eight or 10 miles, both Washington and Gist became concerned that he was taking them in the wrong direction — northeast instead of south, toward Virginia.

Several miles later, he led them to a meadow, where he shot at them.

Neither was hit, and Washington and Gist were able to capture him. Gist advocated killing their “guide,” but his companion wouldn’t allow it. “Washington didn’t want blood on his hands,” Mr. Gasch said. “One of his goals on the trip was to try to befriend the Indians, because both the British and the French wanted the Indians on their side. It could have hurt Indian relations.”

Advertise with us

Rather, they sent the young man on his way, giving him a cake and saying they would catch up with him. Instead, Washington and Gist travelled on their own in the other direction toward Pittsburgh, walking through the night to get away.

Some historians believe that the Native American was sent by the French to kill Washington, said Mr. Gasch.

“They were just months away from building Fort Duquesne,” he said. Had the murder been accomplished, “It may have been a year before Dinwiddie figures out that Washington and Gist were murdered.”

The name of the town likely came from Washington, himself, said Martin O’Brien, president and chairman of the Washington Trail 1753 group. “They attempted to murder him, and he called it Murdering Town,” he said. “We don’t know. but that seems to be the origin.”

In 1935, the Daughters of the American Revolution erected a monument to the shooting attempt after asking a group of professors to determine where the shooting occurred. The plaque is on Route 68 near the Forward Township Municipal Building though the location of the plaque isn’t exact — it was moved from its original spot in the 1960s when Route 68 was moved.

Advertise with us

Historic Harmony is doing a re-enactment of the shooting Saturday at the Jennings Environmental Education Center in Slippery Rock. There are also guided history hikes and nature walks that require reservations, with events starting at 9:30 a.m.

The Harmony Trail, along the Connoquenessing Creek, is where some historians think George Washington's Murdering Town was located. (Courtesy Rodney Gasch of Historic Harmony)

The location isn’t where the shooting actually happened, but “we forgo historical accuracy for having flush toilets and a place to have a piece of cherry pie,” said Mr. Gasch.

As for Murdering Town, which was more than a dozen miles away from the shooting, various historians have taken a stab at the exact location.

In 1930’s “The Principal Indian Towns of Western Pennsylvania,” C. Hale Sipe identifies the likeliest spot for Murdering Town as “the Indian town near the present Amberson’s bridge, on the Connoquenessing a few miles from Evans City, Butler County.” Another historian, Paul A.W. Wallace, wrote in his 1965 book “Indian Paths of Pennsylvania” that Murthering Town is near Harmony.

In more recent times, historian Kevin Patrick Kopper has said that Murdering Town referred to a collection of villages along the Connoquenessing Creek, while another historian, Carl Robertson, locates it in a wooded area near the intersection of Hartmann Road and Prospect Road in Forward.

Advertise with us

For his part, Mr. Gasch and the folks at the Harmony Museum think it was “in or near Harmony,” he said. “That’s our story, and we’re sticking to it.”

“The name has an impact — it’s like a murder mystery and we want to figure it out,” he said. “The reality is, we probably never will.”

Anya Sostek: asostek@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1308.