This story is part of The Neighborhood, a project in which PG reporters focus on Pittsburgh neighborhoods and communities, and directly answer questions submitted by readers. Submit your question here, or at the bottom of this story.
Erin Lowry asks, “What’s the obsession with fries on EVERY SINGLE salad?”
If you see “Pittsburgh Salad” on a menu, you can be sure it has french fries and cheese, and probably steak, too.
You would think that this kitchen-sink concept — meat, vegetables and potatoes — of putting together a salad may be traced to the same time constraints that inspired the “Pittsburgh Steak” — and you may be right. The Pittsburgh Steak is charred on a very high heat on the outside and nearly raw on the inside. The quick-cook steak was how mill workers were able to get a steak dinner in a minute on very short breaks.
According to research by Sarah Grey of Serious Eats, workers would bring in raw steaks and place them on “the big pipes that bring the hot air into the furnace, and they can get as hot as 1,800 degrees Fahrenheit. The guys used to bring their food wrapped in foil and put it on the pipes to heat up — probably not for more than a minute,” said Ron Baraff of Rivers of Steel National Heritage Area.
Today, “Pittsburgh rare” is defined on cooksinfo.com as “a degree of doneness … considered to be an internal temperature of 110 Fahrenheit. The steak should be very charred on the outside, even having black bits on it, but very rare (as in blood red) and still quite cold on the inside.”
Read More
But back to fries on salads.

It may just be that busy Pittsburghers started piling on pieces of a meal as they became ready and eating them all at once. Or it may be the invention of Jerry’s Curb Service, a diner that originated in Ohio but now is in Bridgewater, Beaver County.
Seriouseats.com tells a story about the Pittsburgh salad possibly being invented at Jerry’s. The website, no longer active, claimed: “It was on a fateful night in the early 1960s. … A customer placed a rather unusual order — a steak sandwich, hold the bun, add fries and salad dressing. Not one to disappoint a customer, Donna Reed [wife of owner Jerry Reed] placed the order. She noticed the man cut up the steak, mixed in the fries and poured the salad dressing on top. Curious about this rather odd concoction, Donna decided to try it for herself, but with one small change. Donna placed her sliced steak, fries and salad dressing atop a fresh bed of lettuce."
Another restaurant, Hilltop Grill (since replaced by The Fairport) in Rochester, Pa., also claimed to be the salad's originator.
Looking for a definitive answer, Serious Eats turned to Bob Batz Jr., my desk mate, beer aficionado and former Post-Gazette food editor, who said, “I don’t know how many locals know or would believe the story, but hey, who can dispute it?”
We know, of course, that fries on sandwiches can be traced to Primanti Bros. way back to 1930s. That story, too, includes a restaurant and workers in search of fast food.
Joe’s cousin John DiPriter is quoted on the Primanti's website as explaining: “One winter, a fella drove in with a load of potatoes. He brought a few of ’em over to the restaurant to see if they were frozen. I fried the potatoes on our grill and they looked pretty good. A few of our customers asked for them, so I put the potatoes on their sandwiches.”
The Associated Press, in a 2014 travel story, had its own theory, saying, “Local folklore has it that the sandwiches with the french fries and cole slaw were originally served that way for hurried produce truck drivers working nights without the time for three separate dishes.”
And Erin, if you like steak salads without fries and you like to cook, here’s a recipe. Or, when ordering out, be sure the salad menu item doesn’t include the word “Pittsburgh.”
Sharon Eberson: seberson@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1960. Twtter: @SEberson_pg.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.