A dispute between Edgewood and a popular breakfast and lunch spot in Regent Square over outdoor dining has been temporarily resolved, but borough officials say they plan to review their regulations to avoid confusion in the future.

The borough cited the Square Café in September for multiple violations of its outdoor seating regulations, including having tables too close to the curb, failing to provide enough space for pedestrians, and allowing sidewalk dining year-round.

Edgewood’s permit application for sidewalk cafes does not allow for outdoor seating from November through February. The threat that the restaurant would have to close that seating during those months caused a stir, with fans of the restaurant’s lemon berry ricotta pancakes and breakfast bowls concerned that they may no longer get to enjoy those and other items outdoors year-round. Large heat lamps have long made this an option.

At separate meetings in October, the Borough Council voted not to revoke the café’s outdoor dining permit, and to let it keep its sidewalk seating until the end of the year. The restaurant can submit a new permit application for 2020. In the meantime, the borough will review its ordinance on sidewalk cafes, and will weigh whether outdoor dining should be allowed all year, said council President George Fuller.

Advertise with us

The saga began when Edgewood officials observed that the Square Café’s outdoor seating violated its permit, borough Manager Rob Zahorchak said.

Mr. Zahorchak said that the seating posed a public safety concern because some tables were too close to the parking lane. He added that some people complained that it can be hard for pedestrians to walk through the dining area.

The borough sent the café owners a letter, citing it for multiple violations, including not providing enough space for pedestrians, blocking a ramp, placing seats too close to the curb, having umbrellas and planters, and operating outdoor dining all year, according to Square Café owner Sherree Goldstein.

Ms. Goldstein said that she addressed the first three issues, but asked the borough to reconsider the last two.

At a meeting on Oct. 9, the council fined Ms. Goldstein $100, but allowed her to keep her outdoor seating permit.

Advertise with us

On Oct. 21, the council voted to extend Square Café’s outdoor seating until the end of the year.

Businesses in Edgewood must reapply for an outdoor seating permit every year. For 2020, the Square Café will need to provide a more formal site plan for the sidewalk seating area, Mr. Zahorchak said.

Mr. Fuller said the borough will soon begin reviewing Edgewood’s outdoor dining ordinances, and the council will vote on any changes. Mr. Fuller added that he wants to get comments from business owners, but they won’t be involved in the initial redrafting.

One issue that officials will look at – and which led to confusion for the Square Café – is that the borough’s permit application and sidewalk café ordinance differ on whether outdoor seating is allowed year-round. The ordinance is silent on that matter, but the permit application states that sidewalk cafes are only allowed from March 1 to Nov. 1. Mr. Zahorchak said that limitation is in place so that it is easy to remove snow and apply salt in the winter.

Mr. Fuller said one option may be to give variances to businesses that want to have outdoor seating all year. He added that while he would not eat outside “at a temperature of 20 degrees,” he is fine if others want to do it.

Advertise with us

“I don’t like sitting outside, but, by having that option, it’s easier for me to get a seat inside,” Mr. Fuller said.

To Ms. Goldstein, that’s one reason the outdoor area is key to Square Café, which is especially busy on weekends.

“We can employ more people, seat more people, serve more people and contribute to the community more because everything is larger scale,” she said.

Ms. Goldstein criticized how the borough handled this situation, and questioned why other businesses weren’t cited too.

She said that she wants to participate in efforts to revise the ordinance.

Advertise with us

“I think it’s important that the community works together, all sides are heard, and we do what’s best for everybody,” Ms. Goldstein said.

From inside the Square Café on a recent morning, many diners spoke fondly about the sidewalk seating.

“It makes it homey and inviting,” said Patrice Johnson of Penn Hills.

Alan Green, of Squirrel Hill, said that the outdoor area adds “a feeling of being welcome, like a small town.” As long as a path remains open for pedestrians, he said he’s all for it.

Mr. Zahorchak saw the benefits of sidewalk seating, too.

Advertise with us

“Edgewood borough absolutely supports outdoor dining,” he said. “We think it adds to the business district, but it has to be done in a reasonable and safe manner.”

Jamie Schuman, freelance writer: suburbanliving@post-gazette.com