People voice concerns over gas development in Braddock

Almost all of the two dozen written comments submitted to the state Department of Environmental Protection so far are in opposition to Merrion Oil & Gas Co.’s proposal to drill a shale gas well next to U.S. Steel Corp’s Edgar Thomson steel mill in the Mon Valley.

At Wednesday evening’s DEP public meeting in a cavernous Braddock fire hall, regulators heard more of the same. Except louder. And angrier.

More than 30 of the 200 people in attendance lined up at a microphone to ask questions and tell DEP officials and representatives of U.S. Steel and Merrion Oil & Gas Corp., which has a lease to drill but no state permits yet, that they don’t want the well and the public health and safety risks they say it will bring.

“You’re not drilling under an industrial site,” said Jeamour Matthew, a resident of North Braddock. “You’re proposing to drill under my community, my house and my businesses and roads.”

Advertise with us

“The steel industry has a history of dumping in our rivers and this is going to do the same damn thing,” said John Paylor, a Braddock resident. “I’m opposed to this because it’s not going to do anything for the people who live here.”

Other drilling opponents said they were concerned about the public health and safety impacts of siting a shale gas well in a densely populated area where industrial emissions from coke and steel making mills already make the Mon Valley’s airshed one of the most polluted in the nation.

Approximately 21,000 people live within a 2-mile radius of the proposed well site, located between Braddock Avenue and Turtle Creek on U.S. Steel-owned property that straddles the North Versailles-East Pittsburgh border and is within the eastern property line of the 145-year-old steel mill.

New Mexico-based Merrion has never drilled an “unconventional” horizontal shale gas well anywhere, or any other type of oil or gas well in Pennsylvania. The company, founded in 1950, does have extensive experience drilling “conventional” vertical wells in New Mexico, Colorado, Wyoming and Montana, and according to Ryan Davis, Merrion’s operation manager, many of those in “urban” neighborhoods of Farmington, N.M.

“We’re a very reputable, longstanding, family-owned company committed to safety and to the communities in which we operate,” Mr. Davis told the raucous crowd, which demonstrated its disbelief by coughing loudly.

Advertise with us

U.S. Steel has said it will be a customer for gas produced by the well and views the project as an opportunity to control fuel costs and improve the competitiveness of its two Mon Valley Works steel mills.

According to the erosion and sedimentation permit application under review by the DEP, the project will disturb 13.4 acres for construction of an unconventional gas well pad, two access roads, five freshwater storage tanks, a 2,770-foot natural gas pipeline and a 2,990 foot freshwater pipeline.

Megan McDonough, an organizer with Food & Water Watch, an environmental advocacy organization, called on the DEP to suspend its review of the Merrion permits because of multiple deficiencies in the company’s permit applications and the illegal issuance of required conditional use permits by the municipalities of East Pittsburgh and North Versailles.

“The Mon Valley is being used as a sacrifice zone for the rest of Allegheny County and that has to stop,” Ms. McDonough said. “We have a voice and it matters and you bet your [behind] we will be heard.”

Earlier this week, PennFuture, a statewide environmental organization, launched the “Toxic neighbor Campaign,” aimed at getting U.S. Steel to improve air pollution emissions from its Clairton Coke Works.

Advertise with us

The campaign, advertised in bus shelters, in print and digital platforms, is urging residents of the region to sign a petition or contact the steelmaker directly about reducing air pollution from the nation’s biggest coking facility.

The campaign’s message urges the company to retire the coke works oldest and dirtiest coke batteries (Nos. 1, 2 and 3), invest in upgrades to reduce emissions and be more transparent about plant operations, especially in emergency situations.

“These are not extreme measures,” said Jacquelyn Bonomo, Pennfuture president and chief executive officer. “We are presenting reasonable and rational solutions to the decades-old problems of poor air quality and unhealthfulness. We are advocating for plant improvements that will address toxic pollution and allow industrial jobs to continue in the future.”

A 30-day public comment period on the well proposal ends Monday, and Scott Perry, DEP’s deputy secretary for oil and gas, said he expects the department will make a decision on the project’s permits “within the next several months.”

Comments can be submitted via mail to DEP's Southwest District Office: Oil and Gas Program Manager, 400 Waterfront Drive, Pittsburgh, PA 15222, Attention: Brian Bailey, P.E.

Advertise with us

Comments should include the name, address and telephone number of the person submitting the comments; identification of the permit application number (ESP070218-001), and statements in favor of or objecting to the earth moving permit. DEP also is reviewingMerrion's application for a Utility Line Stream Crossing (GP05020718002) and Well Drilling and Operation permits (003-22563).

Project documents under consideration by DEP are available for review on DEP's website.

Don Hopey: dhopey@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1983, or on Twitter @donhopey