Monroeville council voted unanimously Tuesday to prevent Facebook users from commenting on the municipality’s Facebook page, making it an information-only destination.

The action was taken after former mayoral candidate Chad Stubenbort complained to council critical comments he posted on the page about Monroeville’s plans to impose fees to pay for its new pollution control and flood reduction program had been deleted.

The fees are to pay for one of the federal Environmental Protection Agency’s most expensive mandates called MS4 requirements, which will force municipalities to remove thousands of pounds of sediment from streams.

In September, engineers from MS Consultants, the firm helping Monroeville to meet the MS4 requirements, distributed a handout saying the top 20 fee-payers for the project would include Monroeville Mall, with a yearly payment of $222,840 per year; Gateway School District, with a yearly payment of $91,920 per year, and Forbes Hospital, with a yearly payment of $45,960 per year.

Advertise with us

Manager Tim Little said Monroeville’s disclaimer that no profane or very insulting comments could be posted on its Facebook page was the only policy governing that page.

He said an IT worker employed by Monroeville had shown him a number of comments posted on the page in the past, and was instructed to remove them.

Mr. Little said he didn’t see Mr. Stubenbort’s comments, but said the IT worker in the past had discretion to remove inappropriate comments from the Facebook page. At the same time, Mr. Little said he is the one responsible for all comments posted or deleted from the website.

Mr. Stubenbort provided a screen shot of comments he said were removed from the Monroeville Facebook page. They weren’t profane or insulting, he said.

In his comments, Mr. Stubenbort said the MS4 fees will be passed along to consumers when they shop at stores and at their houses of worship, which must also pay the fees.

Advertise with us

“We’ll pay for it again in our school taxes as they have to pass the cost on to taxpayers,” Mr. Stubenbort wrote. “We’ll also pay for it in our municipal taxes, as Monroeville themselves have to pay this tax too.”

Mr. Stubenbort referred to the MS4 fees as a “tax” several times in his comments.

Mr. Little said after the Tuesday night meeting that all comments on the municipal website must be accurate.

Among the comments by Mr. Stubenbort that were deleted was one pertaining to censorship by the municipality.

“Why is Monroeville censoring its citizens?” he wrote. “What happened to free speech?”

Advertise with us

Before the vote Tuesday night, municipal Solicitor Robert Wratcher said the ACLU has taken the position that on a Facebook page that serves as a public forum, “you can’t take down” one opinion in favor of another.

Mr. Wratcher said it is his opinion that it is not illegal to take down Facebook comments at this time, though the matter will eventually be decided by the U.S. Supreme Court.

He said he believes the high court’s opinion would be “if you allow comment, you have to allow everybody’s comment.” During the meeting, Mr. Wratcher said council also had the option to remove the public comment function from its Facebook page.

Mr. Little said until the law says otherwise, Monroeville has the right to delete any comments from its Facebook page. Citizens have the right to express their opinions during council meetings, he said.

Anne Cloonan, freelance writer: suburbanliving@post-gazette.com.