Monroeville has filed suit against Allegheny County and its elections division contending a recently appointed councilman did not have to run in the May Primary election.

Last year, Ward 2 Councilman Nick Gresock was elected mayor of Monroeville and sworn into office Jan. 2. On Jan. 9 council appointed Democrat Eric Poach to fill Mr. Gresock’s vacant seat. Mr. Gresock’s term was set to expire at the end of 2019.

Monroeville’s Home Rule Charter states an appointed councilperson filling the a vacated seat must run in the next election, which would have been the May 15 primary.

However, that’s not what the Elections Division told representatives of Mr. Poach, who tried to file his nominating petitions in March.

Advertise with us

According to the complaint filed in Allegheny County Common Pleas Court, Mr. Poach was under the assumption that his appointment to the Ward 2 seat would expire on Dec. 31, 2018.

Monroeville Manager Tim Little said Mr. Poach obtained the required signatures and filed a petition to run in the May 15 primary. Mr. Little added on March 6 another member of council, acting on Mr. Poach’s behalf, went to the Division of Elections office to turn in Mr. Poach’s nominating petitions.

Mr. Little said employees of the Division of Elections told Mr. Poach’s representative there was no election for local officials on the primary ballot and refused to accept the nominating petitions.

According to state election code, elections for local office can only appear on the ballot in odd-numbered year statewide elections.

Mr. Little said Mark Wolosik, director of the Division of Elections, contacted him later in the day on March 6 requesting more information about the Ward 2 seat.

Advertise with us

Mr. Wolosik and the county declined to comment. Amie Downs, spokesperson for Allegheny County said it is county policy to not comment on legal matters.

According to the complaint, after Mr. Little spoke with Mr. Wolosik, the municipality sent a letter to the Division of Elections dated March 13 indicating Monroeville Council filled the vacant Ward 2 seat for the term ending in December 2019. The complaint states the municipality heard nothing further from the Division of Elections.

However, following the May 15 primary, the municipality became aware the Ward 2 council seat was on the Democrat and Republican ballots and 28 votes were written in for the seat. No write-in candidate won enough votes to get on the general election ballot in November, according to Mr. Little.

“The presence of the Second Ward council seat on the 2018 primary ballot with no candidate’s name and only the provision for a write-in vote created significant confusion among the voters of the Second Ward and throughout the municipality,” read the complaint.

The complaint states Mr. Wolosik advised Mr. Little despite the March 13 letter from Monroeville advising the filling of the council seat through 2019, the seat was placed on the primary ballot as a write-in position and it was intended to be placed as a write-in position for the Nov. 6 election as well.

Advertise with us

“It’s a matter of what’s in control - the state election law or the home rule charter?” Mr. Little said.

He added the question now becomes, “does he run in November or mount a write-in campaign?”

Mr. Poach could not be reached for comment.

The complaint goes on to state if the write-in position for the seat is permitted to appear on the Nov. 6 ballot, “citizens of the Second Ward of the Municipality of Monroeville will be subjected to further confusion, resulting in a diminution of the election process and the disenfranchisement of Second Ward voters in the municipality.”

Monroeville is seeking to prevent the Division of Elections from placing the seat on the ballot in November and is also seeking declaratory relief to confirm that provisions of state election code which limit election of local officials to odd-number year elections supersedes Monroeville’s Home Rule Charter.

Deana Carpenter, freelance writer: suburbanliving@post-gazette.com.