BEDFORD, Pa. — Long before he was accused of shielding sexual partners from strict prosecution, before he was charged with revealing the identities of confidential informants and before his nearly two-decade career came crashing to a halt last week, District Attorney William J. Higgins Jr. built a life for himself in this rural community.
He arrived as a junior lawyer and a city kid, transplanted from North Philadelphia to this small, quiet town — the sort of place where people stop to chat with each other as they drive slowly down the main road lined with historic buildings.
Mr. Higgins initially seemed ambitious but earnest, motivated by doing the right thing on the job, according to interviews with law enforcement sources familiar with the case against the now-embattled ex-prosecutor. The sources asked to speak on the condition of anonymity because they were not authorized to speak publicly about the case.
But after Mr. Higgins was elected as the county’s district attorney, “his ego got the best of him,” one said. Mr. Higgins, said the source, clashed with investigators, who in turn became suspicious of his prosecutorial decisions. Among them were state police and attorney general’s officials who, off and on for more than a decade, had concerns about how Mr. Higgins conducted himself in office, the sources said.
“He transformed into an arrogant, egotistical individual who thought he was above the law,” the source said.
After the charges were filed, Mr. Higgins, 43, quickly submitted a letter to county officials saying that he intended to “resign/retire ... effective immediately.” In a statement provided through his attorney, he said, “I have been accused of engaging in conduct unbecoming of a district attorney, but more importantly, unbecoming of a husband and father.”
Read More
He declined to address the specifics of the charges “for legal reasons.”
A ‘Philly kid’ put on probation
As a teenager in the 1990s, Mr. Higgins attended school in North Philadelphia, where he laid the groundwork for his future legal career by participating in mock trial. He competed alongside other now-prominent politicians, including U.S. Rep. Brendan Boyle, D-Montgomery.
“My family was not a family of lawyers, and like many kids at Cardinal Dougherty High School, I grew up needing to work — as I did at the local 7-Eleven,” he wrote in a 2010 Pennsylvania Bar Association newsletter. “Because of the mock trial program, the prospect of me becoming a lawyer became more of a reality.”
Mr. Higgins went to Villanova University, according to an online biography, then Widener University Delaware Law School in Wilmington. He later won an alumni award from Widener.
In 1998, while he was 23 and in his second year of law school, Mr. Higgins and a friend were convicted of simple assault after prosecutors said they beat up fans of the Green Bay Packers during an Eagles game at Veterans Stadium, court records and news clippings show.
The Packers fans said Mr. Higgins and his friends, their faces painted in Eagles colors, cursed them, pushed them, ripped their clothes and punched them. One 50-something schoolteacher said she was knocked out and later suffered from recurrent headaches. Mr. Higgins, who said he had downed four beers before the game, denied being the aggressor but was contrite.
“I would apologize for everything that happened,” he testified, “and I apologize to the court for having to go through all this.”
Judge William Meehan put Mr. Higgins and his friend on probation and later trimmed the probation so it wouldn’t block Mr. Higgins from taking the bar exam.
“I think you’ve learned your lessons, and I don’t believe I am going to see you back in criminal court,” the judge said at sentencing.
But Mr. Higgins had trouble finding a job as a lawyer in the Philadelphia area, David Trevaskis, a Philadelphia-area lawyer and mentor to Mr. Higgins, recalled.
Eventually, Mr. Higgins found his way to Bedford County, where he was hired in the district attorney’s office.
Successful elections
Mr. Higgins now lived in a much smaller community. The entire county, which includes multiple state game lands, has a population roughly the size of Harrisburg. A solidly Republican area — it consistently selects GOP presidential candidates by margins of roughly 50 percentage points — Bedford provided fertile ground for Mr. Higgins’ election efforts.
A few years after his arrival, he challenged Dwight Diehl, the same district attorney who employed him, in a tense race. Mr. Higgins, backed primarily by small donations, accused Mr. Diehl of plea bargaining too many cases.
About a month before their Republican primary, an anonymous letter was entered into a court filing accusing Mr. Higgins of holding back information in the case of a state police trooper charged with trying to auction off stolen police gear over the internet. The writer claimed to have overheard Mr. Higgins speak of conversations that “will never come to light” but in which information was exchanged that “would hurt the case,” the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette reported at the time. Mr. Higgins strongly denied the accusations and said that an anonymous letter should carry no weight in court decisions.
Mr. Higgins beat his former boss, receiving 71 percent of the vote in the GOP primary. He went on to win the general election and took the helm of the district attorney’s office for the first time in 2004.
In the years that followed, he oversaw cases involving an attorney accused of molesting a girl, drug sweeps and an attempt to solve the mystery behind an unidentified set of remains nicknamed “Mr. Bones.”
One of his most high-profile cases came in 2008, when he prosecuted a rare, high-profile death penalty case. The suspect, Joseph Clark, now 58, was accused of taking a woman named Holly Notestine from in front of her mobile home, where she had been bathing her two small children. He then kidnapped her and lit her car on fire.
The first time the case went to a jury, it ended in a mistrial because the jurors couldn’t reach a unanimous verdict. The second time, it ended with a conviction for first-degree murder and other charges. The jury spared Clark the death penalty after his attorney argued that he had been physically and emotionally abused as a child and suffered from a “generalized mental dysfunction.”
Just weeks later, news broke that a woman had filed a private complaint alleging that Mr. Higgins had sexually assaulted her in the courthouse following a meeting of the Bedford County Republicans. Mr. Higgins, who at one point was the group’s vice chair, told the Post-Gazette at the time that he had committed adultery but not a crime.
Then-Attorney General Tom Corbett, a Republican whose office had coordinated some investigations with Mr. Higgins’ office, declined to file charges. A spokesman said at the time that the complaint lacked “physical evidence” and “credible specificity,” and that there was “significant evidence which contradicts the allegations,” though he would not outline that evidence.
That 2008 allegation was a turning point. Although charges were never filed in that case, state police and the attorney general’s office continued to field complaints against Mr. Higgins from defendants and others who came into contact with him, culiminating in the charges filed last week, according to sources familiar with the investigation.
Mr. Higgins squeaked through his next election, in 2011, narrowly defeating Democratic challenger Kristin Banasick by fewer than 200 votes, according to county records. It was an unexpectedly tight race for the conservative area.
His next election, in 2015, was easier. Mr. Higgins didn’t have a challenger, though a few candidates did receive write-in votes.
On Jan. 4, 2016, Mr. Higgins signed his oath of office for the fourth time, agreeing to uphold the state and national constitutions — “So help me God.”
This past week, the attorney general’s office and state police filed 31 criminal counts against Mr. Higgins. Investigators have accused him of helping women with whom he had oral sex dodge confidential informants or offering them favorable treatment, such as lighter sentences or lower bail. In one instance, they said, he refused to approve a search warrant in a drug case, despite information from two eyewitnesses.
Mr. Higgins’ attorney said he maintains his innocence. Attorney General Josh Shapiro, a Democrat, called Mr. Higgins’ conduct “a complete betrayal of the trust of the good citizens of Bedford County.”
Post-Gazette staff writer Andrew Goldstein and The Associated Press contributed.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.