At least 21 shots were fired inside a Swissvale home during a December shootout that left a 7-year-old boy and his father dead in what prosecutors are calling a drug deal gone wrong.
Three men were held for court Friday on charges they shot and killed Jo Lawrence Stewart and his father, 29-year-old Walter Stewart, during the Dec. 26 incident.
Donavan L. Wilson, 23, of Rankin, Brandon Barnett, 26, of East Pittsburgh, and his brother, Jacqua Barnett, 30, of Homestead, will stand trial on homicide charges in the deaths.
District Judge Richard G. Opiela dismissed conspiracy to commit homicide charges against all three men during the Friday preliminary hearing in City Court, Downtown.
Allegheny County Assistant District Attorney Lisa Pellegrini presented evidence she said showed that Mr. Stewart went to the home with his son to purchase marijuana but was ambushed by three men inside.
Attorneys for the men argued the evidence was scant and inconclusive, and they suggested that whoever fired at Mr. Stewart did so in self-defense.
Read More
Allegheny County Police recovered three guns. The first, a 9 mm Taurus pistol, was registered to Mr. Stewart, Detective Kevin McCue testified. Mr. Stewart was found dead in the threshold of the home’s front door with his son lying on top of him. The Taurus, which had the slide locked back on an empty magazine, was found near Mr. Stewart’s feet, which were pointed inside the home, testified Thomas Morgan, a member of the county’s mobile crime unit.
Investigators also found a .40 caliber Glock that was registered to Brandon Barnett inside the home. They found no casings or other evidence suggesting the gun had been fired.
A third gun, another 9 mm pistol, was found a day after the homicides about a block away inside a garage on Tomlinson Way, near a jacket that appeared to be covered in blood, Mr. Morgan testified. That gun had been reported stolen in a burglary in North Braddock on Dec. 19, seven days before the killings.
Investigators found 21 9 mm casings and two spent bullets in the home at 1913 Columbia Ave. and on the home’s porch. Twelve of the casings were stamped with the brand “FCNR” and the other nine were stamped with a different brand, “RP,” Mr. Morgan said.
Ms. Pellegrini suggested that the first gunshots came from inside the home and Mr. Stewart returned fire in self-defense. Attorneys for the three men argued that Mr. Stewart fired first.
Mr. Morgan testified that there was no way he could tell from the available evidence who shot first.
Investigators also found in the house a black nylon bag filled with smaller bags of marijuana, Mr. Morgan said. They recovered multiple cell phones.
A jacket that appeared to be covered in blood was found on the outside of the garage on Tomlinson Way where authorities found the pistol; another jacket that also appeared bloody was found nearby in front of 1914 Delaware Ave.
Investigators have sent the guns and jackets for DNA and ballistics testings, but those tests have not yet been completed, Ms. Pellegrini said.
In the absence of that evidence, attorneys for the men argued that the commonwealth could not prove who fired the fatal shots and charges should be dismissed.
“My client's firearm wasn’t fired,” said Ralph Karsh, who represents Brandon Barnett. “My client was shot three times. And I’ve heard no evidence he had anything to do with this shooting.”
Attorney Phil DiLucente, who represents Brandon’s brother, Jacqua Barnett, said his client was never in the home and only took his brother to the hospital after the shooting.
Security footage shows Jacqua Barnett helping his wounded brother into the emergency room at UPMC East, followed by Wilson, according to testimony given Friday. The shooting was reported in a 911 call at 4:30 p.m.
“Nobody knows what happened,” said Ken Haber, who represents Wilson. “They need to get the evidence first and then bring charges.”
A prosecution witness who lived in the home testified that he saw Wilson arrive at the house with two men before the shooting and said Wilson told him to stay upstairs. The 56-year-old man was in his bedroom watching TV a few minutes later when he heard the front door open and then heard a scuffle, he testified.
The witness, who is related to Wilson, said he got up to see what was going on when he heard “a lot” of gunshots and called 911, staying in his bedroom with his back against the door until police arrived. The witness gave conflicting testimony and varying answers to attorneys and admitted he regularly smokes crack cocaine. He said he’d consumed about three-fourths of a quart-sized bottle of Mad Dog 20/20 fortified wine before the shooting but denied being drunk.
The Pittsburgh Post-Gazette is not naming the man because he is in witness protection. He had a heart attack in court March 2, which led to the preliminary hearing being postponed.
Shelly Bradbury: sbradbury@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1999 or on Twitter @ShellyBradbury.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.