Two motions failed to pass at Gateway school board’s meeting last week, both dealing with the issue of transparency in board matters.
Board member Chad Stubenbort has said in the past that resolutions are often brought up shortly before board meetings without opportunity for proper discussion or for the public to comment.
He proposed a resolution at the June 20 meeting that would require a four-day notice on new business before it is voted on at a meeting.
“This is the ‘let’s-not-try-to-get-stuff-10-minutes-before-the-meeting’ resolution,” Mr. Stubenbort said.
His motion to put his proposal on 30-day public display was voted down, 5-4, with Stephanie Byrne, George Lapcevich, Valerie Warning, Steve O’Donnell and Scott Williams opposed. In addition to Mr. Stubenbort, Mary Beth Circuci, John Ritter and Neal Nola voted in favor.
Immediately after Mr. Stubenbort’s resolution failed, Ms. Warning made a motion to increase the annual salary of technology technician Jesse Smillie to $52,500.
Mr. Smillie, one of three technology technicians in the district, is currently an hourly employee, according to director of personnel Patricia Crump.
The measure had not been discussed publicly but had been discussed in a closed board session prior to the meeting.
“This is something we just got an hour ago,” Mr. Stubenbort said.
An assistant technology director was included as a line item in the 2017-18 budget, but Ms. Warning said she was not making a motion to place an individual into that position, just to give Smillie a raise.
Ms. Warning said the raise was warranted because the district just purchased 700 iPads and Mr. Smillie is the only technician certified to work on Apple products.
Mr. Nola said the matter was discussed as a new position in closed session and the board had agreed that it wanted further information on the issue.
“In the back room, we all agreed we needed more discussion on it,” superintendent Bill Short said.
The board gave those in the audience at the meeting an opportunity to comment prior to voting.
Rick McIntyre, who is a candidate for school board, said, “I don’t think it’s the amount of money anybody here’s objecting to.”
He said the main concern was that the position was a new one and it needed to be put out for advertisement.
“I don’t see how you guys as a board can just pick a name and put it in there when this wasn’t even made available to anybody,” Mr. McIntyre said.
The motion to increase Mr. Smillie’s pay failed 5-4 with Ms. Warning, Mr. Lapcevich, Mr. O’Donnell and Ms. Byrne voting in favor of the raise. Mr. Stubenbort, Ms. Cirucci, Mr. Nola, Mr. Ritter and Mr. Williams were opposed.
Mr. Short said after the meeting that the assistant technology director position, which was included in the budget, would have to be publicly advertised before an individual is hired.
Deana Carpenter, freelance writer: suburbanliving@post-gazette.com.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.