A judge has dismissed several criminal counts against a Penn Hills mother whose twins went missing more than a decade ago, finding that prosecutors did not present enough evidence to pursue charges of obstruction, concealment and endangerment.
In a 13-page opinion and order issued Wednesday, Allegheny County Common Pleas Judge Thomas E. Flaherty also criticized the county’s Office of Children, Youth and Families for not conducting follow-up contacts with Patricia Fowler for the past decade.
Judge Flaherty granted a petition filed on behalf of Ms. Fowler, 48, to dismiss charges of obstruction of justice, two counts of concealing the whereabouts of a child and endangering welfare of children in connection with missing twins Ivon and Inisha Fowler, who would be about 18 now.
The judge wrote that prosecutors had not established the basic evidence needed to pursue those charges, but he allowed a count of unsworn falsification to authorities to remain. Defense attorney Aaron Sontz did not challenge another pending charge of conspiracy.
In addition, a separate criminal case is pending against Ms. Fowler for receiving welfare benefits for the twins. Mr. Sontz is also representing Ms. Fowler in that case.
Mike Manko, spokesman for the county district attorney’s office, said Thursday that prosecutors were reviewing the judge’s decision.
Read More
The DA’s office has two options: It can refile the charges with new evidence or it can appeal to state Superior Court.
Ms. Fowler’s twins have not been seen for more than a decade. Authorities have accused Ms. Fowler of telling several different stories about what happened to the children, all of them deemed to be untrue.
The criminal cases against Ms. Fowler began to unfold in July 2016, when four of her children were removed from her home in Penn Hills because of concerns about medical neglect.
During the course of the investigation by CYF, concerns were raised as to the whereabouts of Ivon and Inisha, who would have been juveniles at the time. A CYF caseworker went to Penn Hills Police for assistance.
During interviews with police, Ms. Fowler gave varying accounts about where the twins were, including that they were staying in another state with relatives and that she had sold them.
Judge Flaherty noted that the boy twin, Ivon, was burned at age 2 and received no follow-up care. CYF investigated, but did not report the incident to police or file a dependency petition. The twins’ father, Datwon Lyons, told the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette that Ivon had been scalded in the bathtub in 2000, spent nearly three weeks in a hospital burn unit and was burned over 40 percent of his body.
In October 2006, the judge wrote, a CYF caseworker said during a dependency court hearing that Ivon “reports to be doing well staying with relatives in North Carolina and attending school regularly.” The caseworker made the same statement about his sister, Inisha, the judge wrote.
At another hearing five months later, however, “CYF made an emergency motion to close the twins’ case on the basis that their whereabouts were unknown,” according to Judge Flaherty. “Testimony at that hearing established that a CYF case worker documented that she had seen the twins and they appeared well. However, CYF was not able to validate that the two children viewed were actually the twins, as the child presented as Ivon did not have any scars from the severe burns he suffered in 2000.”
In his opinion, Judge Flaherty wrote: “It is disheartening, to say the least, that CYF failed to conduct any follow-up as to the status of these children for approximately ten (10) years. This failure has contributed to the lack of evidence regarding the welfare of Ivon and Inisha that is available to the Commonwealth and, in turn, this court.”
A CYF spokeswoman wrote in an email that “the PA Child Protective Services Law precludes comment.”
in addressing each of the charges, Judge Flaherty wrote that there was no evidence to indicate Ms. Fowler obstructed a child abuse case because police were conducting a missing-persons investigation, and there was no evidence that Ms. Fowler committed any act constituting child abuse under the legal definition. There was no report of child abuse filed against Ms. Fowler, the judge noted.
“The only evidence of record in this matter concerning potential abuse to the children occurred in 2000 and was deemed by CYF not to rise of the level of abuse,” the judge wrote.
As for concealing the children’s whereabouts, the judge wrote that the children’s father believed the twins were in North Carolina. He was incarcerated at the time and had no idea they were unable to be found there until police told him last year.
“There is simply no evidence that [Ms. Fowler] intended to conceal the whereabouts of the children from their biological father at the time they were removed from the residence.”
Finally, as for the endangering charge, “there is no evidence of record to establish that the children have suffered from any sort of malady or improper care,” the judge wrote. “While this Court surmises that the children’s welfare was likely compromised, the facts as set forth above do not establish that [Ms. Fowler] knowingly endangered the welfare of her children.”
Judge Flaherty denied the defense request to dismiss the unsworn falsification charge, which stemmed from allegations that Ms. Fowler misled police by making false statements concerning her children’s whereabouts.
Ms. Fowler remains in the Allegheny County Jail.
Jonathan D. Silver: jsilver@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1962 or on Twitter @jsilverpg.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.