For the second time in two weeks, a member of the Gateway school board has made a motion to formally censure fellow board member Chad Stubenbort.
The motion failed, 6-3, both times.
In the latest attempt, made Tuesday by board member Steve O’Donnell, Mr. O’Donnell claimed that Mr. Stubenbort used his position as a board member to promote or hire friends to work for the district and to further his own political agenda. In addition, Mr. O’Donnell said, Mr. Stubenbort illegally used a school vehicle and used foul language during closed-door meetings.
Mr. O’Donnell asked that Mr. Stubenbort be removed from board committees and not allowed to speak publicly.
The same allegations of misconduct were made by board vice president Valerie Warning when she made a motion Feb. 7 to censure Mr. Stubenbort.
“The recent board motion to censure me was purely for political reasons with no basis and no evidence. It was despicable,” Mr. Stubenbort said at Tuesday’s meeting prior to the latest motion to censure him.
“The press has asked and I have asked for any evidence whatsoever,” Mr. Stubenbort said. “There’s still no evidence,” he said, calling the allegations “completely baseless.”
Following Mr. Stubenbort’s nearly 30-minute statement, Mr. O’Donnell told him, “This motion to censure was not one developed by me alone. It was developed by five board members.”
On both motions, Scott Williams, Mary Beth Cirucci, George Lapcevich, Neal Nola, John Ritter and Mr. Stubenbort voted against censuring. Mr. O’Donnell, Ms. Warning and Stephanie Byrne voted in favor.
Mr. O’Donnell mentioned an incident earlier this month, in which Mr. Stubenbort spoke against a board decision to not allow first-grader Kamdyn Biddle to finish the school year at Gateway after her family had to move following her father’s death.
“There were real concerns about how you conduct your business throughout the course of your [former board] presidency and up to and including the Biddle scenario,” Mr. O’Donnell said. “It wasn’t one or two or three events. It was the aggregate of them.”
When Mr. Stubenbort asked for evidence of allegations, Mr. O’Donnell said he just hoped that Mr. Stubenbort would realize from the motion the aggregate of the issues and that five people felt so strongly about them to make that motion.
“I personally think the issues can speak for themselves,” Mr. O’Donnell said.
After the meeting, Mr. O’Donnell said that in addition to Ms. Byrne, Ms. Warning and himself, Mr. Lapcevich and Mr. Williams had brought up the idea of censuring Mr. Stubenbort.
Mr. Ritter, who said he received emails after the Biddle incident accusing him of being heartless and self-centered, said he did not want to formally censure Mr. Stubenbort, but he agreed with Mr. O’Donnell’s points.
“When you take the freedom to go out there and speak, recognize that other school board members have to bear the brunt of that and we don’t get to speak sometimes, or we choose not to speak,” Mr. Ritter told Mr. Stubenbort.
Mr. Williams said he agreed with some of the points made by Mr. O’Donnell and Ms. Warning but said, “It’s just time to move on and do school board stuff and keep politics out of here. I hope we can leave all this behind us.”
Deana Carpenter, freelance writer: suburbanliving@post-gazette.com.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.