Katy Biddle said she was up front with the Gateway School District administrators at her daughter’s school from the beginning.
When her husband died after a long battle with brain cancer in September, Ms. Biddle gathered her 6-year-old daughter Kamdyn and her 9-month-old twins and moved into her parents’ house in Murrysville. She went to the principal at Cleveland Steward Elementary and told him where the family moved and why.
“It was just too upsetting to be there, for [Kamdyn] and myself,” Ms. Biddle said about the family’s Monroeville house, which she still owns. “I’m a widow, so I wanted to be closer to my parents.”
She also wanted Kamdyn to finish the year at the school, where she made friends and developed a relationship with the school counselor. But last week, she said, district officials told her that won’t be possible because Ms. Biddle and her children don’t reside at their Monroeville home anymore. The school secretary handed Ms. Biddle a letter as she was leaving her daughter’s parent-teacher conference last week.
“Nobody can understand what’s going on,” she said. “Everybody is kind of just shocked that this is happening.”
Ms. Biddle said even though the principal knew about her situation, school district administrators were not aware that she and her daughter had moved. She tried speaking to Superintendent William Short about it Friday, but he stood by the district’s policy that a child’s residency is based on “where they lay their head at night,” Ms. Biddle said.
Mr. Short could not be reached Wednesday for comment.
Ms. Biddle posted about her plight on Facebook, and it was brought to the attention of school board member Chad Stubenbort. He raised the issue at Tuesday’s board meeting, but the board voted 6-2 to stand by the policy.
“To me it’s not even a policy issue,” Mr. Stubenbort said, adding that he was surprised by the board’s decision. “It’s a humane issue.”
Board member Stephanie Byrne said state statute and district policy requires that a student's parent or guardian physically reside in the school district in order to attend school there.
"I am sympathetic towards the Biddle family," Ms. Byrne said. "I and the entire board wish we could allow the student to stay at Gateway. I cannot imagine the heartbreak that this family has endured. However, I was elected to represent the school district. I will not knowingly violate the law."
Ms. Biddle was able to prove that she owned her house and paid taxes in Monroeville. Her driver’s license lists that address.
“She meets the litmus test of what our board policy says as far as defining a resident,” he said.
Ms. Biddle said she was hoping the district would make an exception for only three more months so Kamdyn could finish the school year. Next year, she would transfer to a new school in Murrysville, where Ms. Biddle just bought a house five minutes away from her parents. “It’s just ridiculous that this is even a conversation,” she said.
She’s been open with Kamdyn about the issue and said the little girl is “devastated” to be abruptly pulled out of her school. She went to class Wednesday to say goodbye to her classmates and Ms. Biddle said she’ll leave it up to her if she wants to go back to school Thursday. She will start school at Sloan Elementary School in Murrysville on Friday.
While Ms. Biddle said she is grateful for the support she received from the principal and school counselor, she’s starting to feel that the abrupt departure is for the best.
“They do make exceptions, I know that for a fact,” Ms. Biddle said. “Clearly, they don’t care for the well-being of my child.”
Elizabeth Behrman: Lbehrman@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1590.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.