A 19-year-old who shot a rival at the Monroeville Mall in 2015 and wounded two bystanders will spend 15 to 30 years in prison, a judge ruled Thursday.
Allegheny County Common Pleas Judge Jeffrey Manning imposed that term on Tarod Thornhill of Penn Hills as his family and one of the innocent victims he shot, Mary Singleton, wept in the gallery.
Following a bench trial last year, the judge found Thornhill not guilty of attempted homicide but guilty of three counts of aggravated assault, four counts of reckless endangerment and two gun charges.
The judge had rejected a defense claim that Thornhill was guilty but mentally ill when he fired inside Macy’s on Feb. 7, 2015.
In court Thursday, he said he would recommend to the Department of Corrections that Thornhill be sent to a prison for youthful offenders where he could receive treatment for mental health problems.
Thornhill shot and wounded Davon Jones and wounded Tom and Mary Singleton, who were shopping with their young son.
Roderick Thornhill, Tarod’s father, apologized through tears to the Singletons and explained that he had not been a part of his son’s life because he had been in jail. But he asked for leniency, saying Tarod has mental health issues and deserves a chance to make his life better.
Mary Singleton told the judge she believed him.
But she also said Thornhill should be held fully accountable for shooting her and her husband and terrorizing her young son. The family had the bad luck to have walked between the shooter and his target.
“I’ve been handed a life sentence because of a choice his son made,” she said. “He didn’t have to pull that trigger. He didn’t have to shoot people.”
Tom Singleton chose not to speak but in a letter to the judge recounted his long, painful hospital stay and his extensive rehab in trying to recover from his wound.
He asked the judge for maximum time for Thornhill.
“Whatever the term of punishment is,” he wrote, “my family and I have already been given a life sentence for the memories and physical effects of Feb. 7, 2015.”
Thornhill briefly addressed the judge and apologized.
“I’m very sorry about the innocent bystanders that I hurt,” he said.
His lawyer, Chris Urbano, said Thornhill is young and can be rehabilitated with proper treatment.
The prosecutor, IIan Zur, countered that Thornhill has a history of violence and crime and questioned how effective treatment would be since it hasn’t worked yet. He was first arrested at age 12 and by 17 had been arrested 11 times and convicted of four felonies.
He also said Thornhill had plenty of time to reconsider his actions on the night of the shooting. He spotted Jones, then went outside to his car to get his gun, came back and opened fire.
Mr. Zur said Thornhill had about two minutes to rethink what he was doing but still fired five times in a crowded mall.
“Fortunately he didn’t kill anyone,” he said.
But he said society needs to be protected from Thornhill.
“He’s a dangerous person.”
Torsten Ove: tove@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1504.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.