A Pennsylvania appeals court on Thursday upheld the prison sentence for a Penn Hills man who injured three people when he opened fire at Monroeville Mall in 2015.
Tarod Thornhill, 23, was sentenced to 15 to 30 years in prison after he was convicted in a 2017 bench trial of three counts of aggravated assault, four counts of reckless endangerment and two gun charges. It was an aggregate sentence that combined multiple concurrent terms attached to each conviction besides the gun charges.
Pennsylvania’s Superior Court affirmed that sentence Thursday.
Thornhill, who was 17 at the time, was targeting a rival at the mall, shooting him three times. But he also shot two people — a man and woman who were at the mall with their young child — in the process.
After his sentencing, Thornhill appealed the judgment and argued that the sentence was unreasonable since the court “failed to perceive” his mental health problems.
At trial, reports from two psychiatrists said Thornhill had a history of psychiatric issues, including chronic adjustment disorder and chronic post-traumatic stress disorder, court documents read.
Read More

Allegheny County Common Pleas Judge Jeffrey Manning, who sentenced Thornhill, acknowledged that he could benefit from psychiatric treatment, saying at the trial that there was “no doubt in my mind ... that he is in need of treatment” and that he was “not going to overlook the treatment concept,” court documents read.
Although Thornhill acknowledged that the court mentioned his diagnoses, he claimed that it “failed to give meaningful consideration” to his youth and mental health issues, Superior Court Judge Maria McLaughlin wrote in the opinion published Thursday.
But Judge Manning delivered a statement from the bench that addressed the overarching concerns of the matter, the court found, noting that he addressed issues of rehabilitation, punishment and deterrence.
He encouraged Thornhill to take advantage of rehabilitation programs in state correctional institutions and said the young man would probably be less likely to commit another crime when he was taken out of “a youthful criminal environment.”
“I never really believed that deterrence actually works, other than to deter the person who was convicted of a crime,” Judge Manning said. “But deterrence sometimes is there to set an example. To send a message.
“We, as a society, need to know that our shopping malls, our schools, our places of worship, our theaters, all public gathering places, are safe havens,” the judge continued. “Places where these kinds of events cannot occur. That also is a consideration of sentencing.”
Citing these statements, Judge McLaughlin said the court thoughtfully considered all of the issues raised by Thornhill.
“While [the court] may not have given them the weight Thornhill contends it ought to have, that does not make the sentence excessive,” she wrote.
Mick Stinelli: mstinelli@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1869 and on Twitter: @MickStinelli






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.