A judge has resolved a Plum school board dispute by giving a former director back her seat — a little more than three months after she resigned right before a controversial vote.
Allegheny County Common Pleas Judge Michael E. McCarthy on Monday appointed Michelle Stepnick to fill out the “current unexpired term” of the board position left vacant when she stepped down in September.
“I’m grateful to be reappointed to my position that I was elected to and looking forward to serving out the next 11 months,” Ms. Stepnick said. “I’m hoping we put this stuff behind us and move forward.”
Ms. Stepnick abruptly resigned Sept. 27 prior to the board voting 4-3 to reinstate superintendent Timothy Glasspool, who had been placed on paid leave during an independent investigation of a sex-abuse scandal that had consumed the Plum Borough School District.
At the time, Ms. Stepnick expressed concerns that some board members were unwilling to accept the findings of the investigation that found no grounds to fire Mr. Glasspool for how he handled various complaints, rumors and allegations of inappropriate behavior by teachers toward students at Plum High School.
Those complaints led to a grand jury investigation and the successful prosecution by the Allegheny County district attorney’s office of three male teachers, all of whom pleaded guilty to institutional sexual assault for having sexual relationships with female students.
Ms. Stepnick changed her mind about stepping down a few days later and argued that her seat was not vacant because the board never voted to accept a written resignation.
The board moved ahead with plans to fill the vacancy and listed Ms. Stepnick among three finalists. But board members said she did not show up for a second round of interviews, and they instead nominated Scott Coulson for the position during a meeting in October. But the board deadlocked 4-4, failing to to reach a majority.
The dispute went to court, leaving Ms. Stepnick to vie for the seat with parent Bill Chapla, who has been a regular and vocal presence at board meetings. P.J. Murray, Ms. Stepnick’s attorney, conceded that the judge could have “pulled somebody out of thin air” to fill the vacancy, but the decision really came down to his client and Mr. Chapla.
In his order, Judge McCarthy indicated that he found that a vacancy was indeed created.
It was not clear why the judge appointed Ms. Stepnick, whose attempt to return to the board generated animosity among a bloc of three of her former colleagues and among some parents, including Mr. Chapla.
In his four-paragraph order, Judge McCarthy wrote that a replacement was not found for Ms. Stepnick, who “satisifes the requisite qualifications of a school director ….”
The judge declined comment and said the order “speaks for itself.”
“Of the two finalists, she’s the only one that’s ever won an election to a school board. Maybe that had something to do with it,” Mr. Murray said.
Board members who opposed Ms. Stepnick’s return expressed disappointment.
“I am not really all that surprised with regards to hearing that she was reappointed by the judge,” board member Steve Schlauch said.
“However, if Ms. Stepnick really wants back on the school board, I have to question her true motive as to why she quit in the first place. I mean it was right before the biggest vote in the district in years with the reinstatement of the superintendent. Then she rescinded her resignation almost immediately after.”
Board member Vicky Roessler also was unhappy.
“I did not support the reinstatement of Mrs. Stepnick, and I do not believe it is in the best interest of the school district for her to return,” Mrs. Roessler said. “With that being said, I am disappointed but I have no other choice but to respect the decision of the judge and move forward.”
Mr. Chapla said he, too, respected the judge’s decision.
Board president Kevin Dowdell said he was “relieved” that Ms. Stepnick was back.
“I think she was the best choice since she has the most experience from the other candidates,” Mr. Dowdell said. “I hope we can now move forward to resolve the issues facing our district.”
Jonathan D. Silver: jsilver@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1962.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.