A judge is expected to decide this week whether a former Plum school board member is allowed to retake her seat after she resigned amid the district sex-abuse scandal and then changed her mind.

Michelle Stepnick, who abruptly resigned in September before a controversial board decision then attempted to rescind that resignation several days later, will make her case to be reinstated at a hearing in Allegheny County Common Pleas Court at 1:45 p.m. Wednesday. Plum resident Bill Chapla also will state his case after asking the court that he be given Ms. Stepnick’s job.

“I think we just kind of want to get it behind us and move forward,” school board president Kevin Dowdell said Monday.

Mr. Dowdell wrote a letter in support of Ms. Stepnick, arguing that her reinstatement would be in the best interest of the Plum Borough School District. She has three years of experience on the school board and its legislative and finance committees, he wrote, and has made trips to Harrisburg on behalf of the district at her own expense.

Advertise with us

Her decision to quit was made “in the heat of the moment,” he said. The resignation came before the meeting in which the board voted 4-3 to reinstate superintendent Timothy Glasspool following an independent investigation of the district sex-abuse scandal in which four current or former Plum teachers were arrested, and three were convicted on institutional sexual assault charges.

“I just thought bringing in someone new at this point, it’s going to take at least six months or so to bring that person up to speed,” Mr. Dowdell said, noting that seat will be up for election again this year.

Mr. Chapla, a longtime Plum resident, parent and alumnus of the school district, wrote in his petition that he frequently attends board meetings and has been actively involved with the new Safe and Supportive Schools Committee, which was formed after the sex scandal that rocked the district in 2015.

“I would like a seat on the school board to provide insight to the board to give you the viewpoint of a resident looking in from the outside,” he wrote in his petition to the judge. “I have serious concerns about the safety and financial issues the district is currently facing. I believe there needs to be change of direction in this district to provide the students and community a school district they can be proud of.”

After the remaining eight school board members deadlocked in a vote to appoint a replacement to fill the vacant board seat, Ms. Stepnick in November filed a motion asking a judge to intervene. On the same day, a group of 11 Plum residents — including Mr. Chapla — filed a similar petition.

Advertise with us

Ms. Stepnick argued that because her resignation was never voted on and accepted by the school board, it was not official. District solicitor Lee Price said in court documents that Ms. Stepnick emailed Mr. Dowdell, board vice president Richard Zucco and other district administrators about her intentions to quit after she walked out of the September meeting.

Ms. Stepnick could not be reached for comment. Mr. Chapla declined to comment pending the outcome of the hearing.

Elizabeth Behrman: Lbehrman@post-gazette.com or 412-253-1590.