The same day 11 Plum residents filed a petition asking a judge to appoint a school director to fill the seat vacated by Michelle Stepnick, the former board member asked the court for an injunction that would let her continue in that role.
The petition filed Thursday by the borough’s tax collector and 10 other residents in Allegheny County Common Pleas Court by attorneys Ronald L. Hicks Jr. and Nicholas J. Bell of Meyer, Unkovic & Scott, does not recommend any particular individual other than a “qualified elector.” If successful, it would break a stalemate that has led the school district to function with an eight-member board because of an inability to agree on a path forward to fill the seat.
Ms. Stepnick resigned before a September meeting at which the board voted to reinstate superintendent Timothy Glasspool following an independent investigation of the Plum Borough School District sex-abuse scandal.
She changed her mind a few days later and argued that her resignation was never official because the remaining eight board members did not vote to accept it. On Oct. 7, Ms. Stepnick tried to withdraw her resignation, according to her complaint and the residents' petition.
Despite Ms. Stepnick’s assertion that the board never voted on her resignation, the petition claims that “by its words and/or acts” the board accepted her decision. The petition documents the steps that were taken following her Sept. 27 resignation by email, such as advertising a vacancy, accepting letters of interest, advertising its plans to move forward with replacing Ms. Stepnick and ultimately narrowing finalists down to three candidates — including Ms. Stepnick.
Two of the three finalists — Scott Coulson and David DiTullio — showed up Oct. 24 for second interviews, but Ms. Stepnick did not. The board failed to appoint a new director because of a 4-4 vote at its meeting the next day.
Read More
Ms. Stepnick's attorney, PJ Murray, argued in a complaint also filed Thursday that under the last two solicitors, the board moved to fill a vacancy only when members "voted affirmatively" to accept the resignation--something the legislative body "has yet to even attempt to do" in this case.
She accused four unnamed board members, led by "faulty legal advice" from solicitor Lee Price, of continuing to "thwart [her] ability to perform her duties." The complaint asks the court to "confirm [her] lawful right to her elected position ... free from any interference from select school board members and the school district solicitor."
According to Ms. Stepnick's filing, Stuart Knade, Senior Director of Legal Services for the Pennsylvania School Boards Association, agreed there was no vacancy on the board. He could not be immediately reached Friday for comment.
The Public School code provides for at least 10 resident taxpayers of a district to petition the court to take action in the event of a board vacancy lasting 30 days.
The residents who signed the petition are: Karen Acquaviva, Paul Anderegg, John Anderson, William E. Chapla, Suzanne Dawson, Scott Fecsen, Denise Fenk, Joan Lucas, Tom Pade, Kristen Sofran and Harry Schlegel.
A hearing is scheduled for Jan. 4.
Last week, Ms. Stepnick’s attorney sent a letter to the district saying she intended to resume her duties and would seek a surcharge against the board if it pursued litigation. Ms. Stepnick was present at the meeting Tuesday, but did not sit with the board members. She took notes and sat among the audience as the board discussed capital projects, next year’s budget and other topics.
Mr. Price said he has not yet seen the petition but does not object to what it is trying to accomplish.
"We want to get a decision from a judge and do whatever at this point," Mr. Price said. "At this point, I don't see any reason why the district would object to it."
Ms. Stepnick declined comment.
Jonathan D. Silver: jsilver@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1962 or on Twitter @jsilverpg. Molly Born: mborn@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1944 or on Twitter @molly_born.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.